MovieChat Forums > All Is Lost (2013) Discussion > The movie 'goes overboard' when Redford ...

The movie 'goes overboard' when Redford fights the giant squid


All suspension of disbelief lost. I was thinking "What's next, mermaids?" 

reply

With the sharks coming in and rescuing him? This was a key moment in the film. As poetic as it was moving, the scene serves as powerful commentary on modern society -- on what we perceive as "evil" versus what evil really is: squishy things. The film is about breasts and men's slavery to them, but I don't think a lot of people really got it.

---
Sad story. Got a smoke?

reply

With the sharks coming in and rescuing him?


Well, that part was cool; it was a good twist after building them up as the bad guys. Plus, I was pretty touched when the main shark and Redford shared a knowing look, and he nodded at it before it returned to the depths. But the giant squid was just too out there for me.



reply

We do agree on the squid being too much. But for me, personally, the buddy-sharks redeemed the film; and indeed, that moment they shared will stick with me for decades to come.

---
Sad story. You got a smoke?

reply

unfunny trolls

reply

Yeah, they are getting as bad as IMDB before they shut it down. That is all there is here now ... trolls.

reply



the giant squid is in his mind!



Autumn is a second spring when every leaf is a flower.-Albert Camus🍁

reply

I thought it went overboard when Redford was trying to kill that White sperm whale from his little raft with that pen he was using to write his journal and then when he grabbed the fins of those two dolphins and started riding on them like water skis just to impress the crew on those tankers when he should have been trying to get them to rescue him.

reply

! spoiler - alert ! The alien spacecraft rising from the sea floor to rescue him

reply

I don't care what anyone says - the moment when the sailor was revealed to be Elvis was a triumph.

reply