In Thor 2 we see that there is a lot more to him, he has brains and strategies. Previously he seemed a bit of a 'meathead', but here he leads armies into battle, tricks his brother and lies to him when necessary, not to mention plans out the taking out the ship from Asgard as a decoy.
None of that is in the movie, you're reading into it.
We don't see Thor leading armies into battle. We see him appear and hit the big rock man. That's an action beat. If you want to fill in the gaps and imagine that Thor was instrumental in planning the offense or something that's fine, but we do not see any such thing in the actual movie.
Same goes for tricking Loki - nothing about the trick came from character attributes of Thor, it was just 'character A pulls the rug from under character B'.
Ditto with taking the ship. There was nothing about that sequence that showed Thor being a canny leader or strategist. In fact, the movie is so slapdash with these sorts of things that maybe the first interaction between Thor and Loki when they board the ship is
Loki: I thought you said you knew how to fly this thing.
Thor: I said 'how hard could it be?'
Personally I think that's just lazy, cliche writing. But if you take it at face value then Thor's plan sucked.
reply
share