MovieChat Forums > Saving Hope (2012) Discussion > Why does Alex hate Charlie's ability wit...

Why does Alex hate Charlie's ability with such vitriol ? It's useful !


We've made it to the end of Season 4 and I feel like barely any headway has been made with Charlie's acceptance of his abilities, but worse, with Alex coming to terms with them. Fair enough, when she believes that the tumor might be the cause of them and that the tumor needs to go because it could potentially kill him. Everything prior to that, though ? She got unnecessarily bitchy about them on a ridiculous number of occasions. Even though Charlie turns out to be right on so many occasions and she has to see that this advantage gives him a leg up in helping his (and others') patients.

At this point, it feels like she's the unreasonably semi-skeptic, almost sometimes willfully blind Scully to Charlie's Mulder (and Charlie could do with getting on board with his abilities and the exploration of them, especially once he saw what psycho-killed-his-wife prisoner guy could do, physically effecting things even while unconsious and in spirit form).

I don't need this show to tweak the balance between straight-up hospital drama with a drop of supernatural medical detective work that much more, because I like its vibe...but a little tweak would be nice, just to allow these characters to feel like they're reacting the way real people might to extraordinary revelations like this, three to four years into experiencing them.

And more characters need to be made aware, so that they're not always covering for Charlie anymore. Who cares if the show risks going off the rails because of it -- be bold and allow forward plot progress (not only where characters' romantic relationships are concerned).

reply

I hope more characters find out before the end of the show. I keep waiting for Shahir to find out and maybe Charlie can somehow prove his ability to him.

While Alex's paranoia most likely saved Charlie's life I also wish she was more on board with his ability. She believes him but wants nothing to do with the ghosts, told him 'I need what's real.' I think if more people knew about Charlie's ability she might not be so turned off but it shows she's not willing to stick her neck out for him at this point.

I think the ghosts will be more prominent than ever next season, so hopefully things will be taken to the next level. I also want the writers to take some more risks in that area.



Milo, I've told you again and again - please, don't walk on the chickens!

reply