MovieChat Forums > Nymphomaniac: Vol. I (2014) Discussion > The three actors that portray Joe, and t...

The three actors that portray Joe, and their physical non-resemblance.


The three actors that play the character of Joe look nothing alike. I have to wonder if this was done intentionally on Von Trier's behalf, if it's making a statement on how we view ourselves through a distorted lense at different eras in our lifetime--on many levels, this is a film about distortions (trying to relay an experience through the imperfect medium of storytelling and etc). I wonder if there is any validity to this theory of mine, or if I'm simply looking into it too deeply?

reply

The little girl indeed only had little resemblance to Gainsbourg, but the adolescent part was tricky to cast. You needed someone with descent acting ability, willing to go full frontal and still look something like Gainsbourg. For me they cast well enough here to not break my Willing Suspension of Disbelief.

__________
Last movie watched: The Best Years of Our Lives (9/10)

reply

Not to mention that Shia Lebeouf and the actor who played Jerome as an older man in Nympho 2 look NOTHING alike, either. And it's not just facial differences, it's body build differences.

The actress who played young Joe is tall, thin, lanky - built like a runway model. Charlotte Gainsbourg is thin and that's about the only similarity. Shia Lebeouf is short and fairly stocky, with a large nose. The actor cast as the older Jerome was obviously much taller, with a smaller nose and square-ish face.

Yeah, people change as they age . . . but not THAT much! I am taller average for a female - 5'9" and built like a brick *beep* It doesn't matter whether I was 2, 28, or 51 as I am now, thinner or fatter (as I am now *lol*), solidly auburn-haired or mostly grey . . . I still look like ME.

On the other hand, VonTrier doesn't seem to care about trivialities like his main characters not looking ANYTHING like their younger or older selves in 'Nympho 1l or '2.' He's too preoccupied with lining up anal sex shots and graphic abortion scenes! :-)

reply

There was actually SIX different actresses that played Joe if I counted correctly! And thats not even counting the "porn doubles". And some of them were so dramatically different from each other (completely different eye color, different ethnicities, etc.) that it seemed clear visual continuity accuracy was far less important to von Trier then actually having the right actor or sending a particular message with the mismatches.

---
Using words to describe art is like using a screw driver to cut roast beef.

reply