Wrong girl

I would have taken Casey's sexier friend. She was skinnier, prettier, taller, and wearing loose layered tank tops and shorts. It looked like she wasn't even wearing a bra! Imagine how much harder the Chloroform would have hit that ridiculously skinny chick than chunky tomboy Casey who was all covered up baring none of the shoulder, neck and leg that her much weaker and prettier friend was. Her friend was so skinny the first whiff of chloroform would have snapped her head back and knocked her right on her soft little ass! She would have been so deeply drugged she wouldn't have come to in the trunk and she wouldn't have had her phone because she left it on the table with Casey. The guy had bad taste in girls. He took the plain girl instead if the girl that was designed to be chloroformed which is for beauties like Rachel Nichols in P2 and Samantha Eggar in The Collector, not boyish Abigail Breslin.