So what do you think?


Checked out the first episode on demand. I have never read the book and went into this without knowing anything about the show. I only read a little blurb about the plot.

I wasn't too impressed. I thought it would be more in a style of Carnivale or something. I just thought it would look nicer. It seemed cheap. It was like a CBS show.

I also thought the scenes ran on too long with excessive dialogue. I thought Ian McShane was great and his acting was top notch. I thought Ricky Whittle (who i wasn't familiar with) was the weak point by far. I found his acting to be pretty bad.

What about you guys?

reply

Let's see: We have opening credits that are a poor man's version of the opening credits for The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo; a scene with Vikings landing in the New World that was clearly inspired by the movie 300 and not as well-done as the Spartacus series; then there's a whole lot of talking; then we cut to a middle-aged guy going on a blind date and winding up in the sack with a woman who asks him to worship her and she winds up--how to put this? hmmm--snatching him up; then our protagonist, Shadow Moon (are you familiar with the artist formerly known as Cat Stevens?) gets himself hired as a majordomo/bodyguard by Mr. Wednesday, who is almost certainly Wotan (Wedesday is derived from Wotansday) while a really bad and annoying Tin Pan Alley song from the 60s plays in the background; then Shadow has a pretty good Donnybrook with a 6 1/2-feet tall Leprechaun; then Shadow buries his dead wife and we get this interesting exchange between he and a friend as Shadow stands over her grave: Shadow: "She's in a better place," Friend: "She is in Parkview Cemetery. Target would be more interesting than this;" then Shadow discoveres a strange, glowing VR headset that sucks him into Cyberspace and introduces him to a Silicon Valley pussy whose opening line is a laughably pathetic "Don't fuck with me," and asks questions to which even a Mongoloid would know that Shadow could not possibly know the answer, then has Shadow beaten up and then some force kills all the beater-uppers. The End. I like Neil Gaiman very much. Stardust and Coraline are in my video library. I am going to give this show a chance. Game of Thrones started slowly. So did Emerald City, and I came to love them both. The production values of American Gods is NOWHERE NEAR the values of ES and lightyears removed from GoT. The spoken exposition is tedious. The cast is promising. If Starz, i.e., CBS, is not lazy, this could--and I stress could--be good. At the moment, that conclusion is not a slam-dunk.

But it will never be great.

Yes, I am disappointed.

reply

What is ES?

reply

Sorry. That should have been EC for Emerald City.

reply

You gave the best summary... I watched the first 2 episodes but not sure if there are more? Also is this season one or two? People are talking about more than I have seen, but maybe they are talking about the book?

reply

Thank you. There are 6 more episodes this season, and it's been renewed for a second season, which means presumably another 8 or more episodes.

This is season 1.

reply

Thanks for clarifying. I think people are talking about the book then. Either way, I will watch and give it a chance. I prefer less of the hocus pocus stuff, but its gritty enough to keep me watching.

reply

Neil Gaiman is so immature and over the top; it's all so cringe. I just hate it. Like everything else Neil Gaiman I only look to see if I'll actually like it and I always hate it. I still can't believe his Death is the Death in the DC Universe. How can this work for a large audience. Whatever.

reply

Let's say: I expected more from Brian Fuller.

reply

Wow, and I thought I'd have the unpopular opinion here! I, too, was disappointed in it. I give it the benefit of the doubt since it's only the first episode, but I can't say I was too enthralled with it. I guess, as some others, I expected more by this coming from Fuller. The style is there, but not so much the substance.

There were moments I liked, and I'll keep up with it for a few more episodes, but if I still feel this indifferent towards it by then I'll probably stop watching.

reply

Fuller typically develops the rich details of his characters. But Shadow was especially vapid. He is clearly just a masculine token character.

reply

If the show stays true to the book, which it did in the opening episode, then it is going to get a lot more carnivale-esque in the future.

reply

This show needs to start moving faster and be headed is an apparent direction. Fifteen minutes into the second episode I realized that literally nothing had happened. Now, I was unimpressed by the first episode of Emerald City, too, but it got my attention with the second episode and I eventually loved it. No such luck here, and we are one-quarter of the way through the series. There is only one point that I've so far discerned from AG: white people coming to the New World was a terrible thing. The Native Americans took one look at us and shot us dead on the spot. We brought slavery to these shores. I wouldn't be surprised if AG eventually shows us crucifying Jesus with our own hands. Finally, there is 'way too much pontificating in the scripts, and 'way too much of it is not just shouted, IT IS ROARED!!! I hope to high heaven that the new Twin Peaks is better than this thing.

reply

I like it a lot!

reply

I'm loving it. Every scene is riveting.

reply

I've never read the book, but I like Brian Fuller's stuff, so I was excited for this. The first two episodes were a disappointment and a bit of a chore to sit through. Scenes were happening, and were going on way too long. And everything looked so dark. Why? Episode 3 I thought was better.

I liked the addition of characters from Slavic mythology. Those are usually overlooked. But that's more in the "That's neat" category, that anything else.

Lots of shows struggle a bit in the first few episodes, so hopefully it gets better from here.

reply