MovieChat Forums > The Batman (2022) Discussion > "Robin Should Be Banned From All Batman ...

"Robin Should Be Banned From All Batman Movies Forever"


One reason so many Batman movies get made is that among comic book heroes, he is NOT a superhero. He has no superpowers. He gets the job done with gadgets and cars and planes and his fighting skills.

In other words: he's James Bond. And thus all these Batman films are really a dark take on the Bond series, and can continue on forever.

But honestly, can you imagine James Bond toting a teenage boy around with him on life-or-death adventures. Or asking the kid to "please wait outside" while he bedded some woman?

One reason that the 1966-era Batman show is looked on with ridicule today -- despite its truly GREAT roster of guest villains, and in addition to the Super Square presentation of Batman/Bruce Wayne -- is ROBIN! Always saying "Holy Pancakes, Batman!" or something and generally behaving like a well behaved teenage brat. The sexiest Catwoman (Julie Newmar) was always trying to get Robin out of the way (including killing him) so she could have Batman all to her sexy self.

I suppose that comics were, at one time, for kids, so having a "kid comic hero" like Robin to go along with Batman was the "kids thing to do."

But Batman went and got serious along the way. It started a bit with Burton(the kinky Batman Returns) solidified with Nolan's series, and now has the dark and violent "The Batman" to continue that trend.

Robin doesn't belong.

He probably never did, because EITHER:

ONE: Robin turns Batman into an older brother figure or, worse, father figure, and turns the Batman series into a "family show."

OR:

TWO: The older man/younger man duo give off "gay vibes' in an ever more savvy and smarmy culture. SNL spoofed this with their "Ambiguously Gay Duo" series; and the two Joel Schumacher films had a gay vibe that the female characters could not break through.. Moreover, TODAY, making Batman and Robin gay jokes is strictly off limits.

Indeed, for whichever of the above reasons, Schumachers' two Batman films -- Batman Forever and Batman and Robin(there, he finally made it into the title) are considered the WORST in the series. Robin kind of messed them up.

I think it is pretty clear than neither Tim Burton nor Chris Nolan wanted Robin in their Batman films -- though Nolan allowed for a "Robin-esque' origin character in The Dark Knight Rises(to follow Batman as the hero, not to join him.) Robin is OUT.

Its probably a given. But it should be a law:

No more "Batman and Robin." No more Robin.

Let Batman live on as a dark, violent, creature of vengeance by night, a suave ladykilling rich guy by day.

Robin is OUT.



reply

How about a Batgirl and Robin movie? They could ride e-bikes.

reply

Batman is just a better character alone. I always thought he came off as awkward when he was in the justice league or teamed up with Robin. This guy is a loner, it's like that joke from Airheads which asks how the band could be The Lone Rangers because there are three of them and therefore they aren't really lone.

reply

If they can make even the silliest of Batman villians work, they can make Robin work.

He doesn't have to be as quippy as Spider-Man, but he can be a light-hearted balance to Batman's broodiness and work as a character the audience can identify with. He's not rich and connected like Bruce is, he's just a kid from the circus. Robin is a major character in the Batman mythos, and as Nightwing he's one of the most popular superheroes in DC comics, if not superheroes in general. I personally think it's weird to have a Batman series without him, even the Nolan movies had him in some form, though I wish they used Dick Grayson and not some original random guy.

They gotta have Robin, with enough effort they can make it work. With that said, I hope they don't color-wash or gay-wash him, or over-emphasize his retconned gypsy roots that have no bearing on his character. If that were the case, then I'd rather them not have Robin at all. Tim Burton almost had a black Robin in the Keaton movies, I'm glad that never happened.

reply

Robin is a girls name as well.
Turn Robin into a badass (Harley Quinn) type.
Hell, make her Batman’s niece.
That’ll kill that love interest stuff.
Why have a Robin at all?
A change of pace I guess.
Her backstory; troubled kid. Wrong crowd. After her boyfriend was killed, by gang members, she does what the Wayne Family does! Recklessly, until Bruce Wayne reels her in and she excels at everything!
Her greatest and most gifted talent?
She’s a gambler.
Stakes that are higher than any dollar amount could ever yield.
She wins when she goes ALL-IN on a matter.
She loses at Black Jack every time she plays!
Her ‘vice’ is a double-edge sword.
18-22 year old beautiful little badass!
Who wouldn’t enjoy that?

Batman: Vengeance

Robin has unfinished business with her lovers killers.
A drug cartel leader who sells kids on the side.
“Getting even never tasted so good.”

Cast your female Robin!
Who’s on the list?

Thinking outside of the box here...
It’s about time for Halsey to break into film!

reply