MovieChat Forums > American Horror Story (2011) Discussion > Just Rewatched MH, Coven,Freakshow and R...

Just Rewatched MH, Coven,Freakshow and Roanoke

posted 6 years ago by billbrown7071 (3195)
2 replies | jump to latest

So last year, I binged watched this entire series for the first time(LOVED IT)

came away when my series rankings being-

Roanoke
Murder House
Coven
Freakshow
Hotel
Asylum
Cult

I did feel Asylum was the best overall season...But Just not my favorite....

In Anticipation to Season 8, I decided to rewatch Murder House and Coven(since they were doing a cross over)

Ended up watching MH, Coven,Freakshow and Roanoke.....and came away with Different opinions now....

I by far enjoyed Freakshow The Most rewatching them for a second time

I found Coven really slowed down and Lost My interest a little toward the 9th episode

Murder House was Just as Good as I remembered and more Special(it was the start of something New and kinda never before seen) watching it a 2nd time, and knowing that it started it all really made the season feel special

and I enjoyed Roanoke Greatly and still feel its criminally underrated by The Majority, but did feel the first 5 episodes are most stronger than the last 5

Also, watching These seasons for a 2nd time, really made it feel Like A Cinematic Universe and felt like they were all connected, watching these seasons the first time, I didnt know they all took place in the same universe, had no clue what or if there was going to be nods or connections to previous or characters overlapping...but watching it the 2nd time, It very much felt kinda like watching "Marvel Cinematic Universe" films where all the films and characters take place in the same universe....watching it a 2nd time, It really did feel like 1 giant story/Universe just telling different tales....

My Rankings Now are

Roanoke
Freakshow
Murder House
Coven
Hotel
Asylum
Cult

I now Feel Roanoke, Freakshow and Murder House are almost a 3 way tie for My favorite seasons...There is just so much I love about each season for some many different reasons...

my question is....If you have watched This series for a 2nd time....did your opinions on the seasons change, did you enjoy a certain season more on a 2nd viewing?

did your Rankings of the seasons change upon 2nd viewings>?

[–] SammiWin (1112) 4 years ago

I know this is old but I started a rewatch for AHS and I started with what I thought was a favorite, Freak Show, but this time around I was more bored and disappointed. Not saying it wasn't "good" I thought the acting was great, but it felt more like a melodrama at times vs. "horror story"

I'm going to watch Asylum next.. not sure what order I should watch them in. Originally I watched Coven live, then Freakshow, Murder House, then Asylum. I've never seen Hotel or Roanoke, I hear very mixed things about both of them, so that will be "interesting". I watched Cult live and I'm dreading to watch that one again.

I enjoyed Murder House, Asylum and Freak Show my first time watching. Since Coven was the first I watched I only thought it was decent, but who knows what I'll think a second time around 7 years later.

I did watch Apocalypse when it aired, I'm mostly annoyed with it because of its inconsistencies. I liked 1984, but like every season of AHS nothing fully seems planned

[–] JaqenHgar (731) 4 years ago

I've watched every season at least 3-4 times, and I can say that my rankings have never changed.

Asylum
Murder House
Coven
Hotel
Freakshow
1984
Apocalypse
Roanoke
Cult