MovieChat Forums > American Horror Story (2011) Discussion > One problem I had with Roanoke

One problem I had with Roanoke


They had teased that Shelby and Matt couldn't be trusted. And that they somewhat lied about how they got out of the house. I'm upset they never really touched on this.

Also I thought matt killed one of the polk boys when he got shot while driving. If that was just made up then what really happened? How did they get out? I'm guessing these questions cant be answered so I guess I Just found a plot hole.

Burn the witch

reply

I think they couldn't be trusted because of their intentions and what they are capable of. Shelby was supposed to love Matt but ended up killing him. Matt cane back for Scathach and not for Shelby.

As for Matt shooting one of the Polk brothers, it's possible that they added that part in for the documentary to make it more interesting. It pretty common for movies and documentaries to do that. I don't think Matt even mentioned that during MRN.

reply

When did Matt shoot a polk? I'm having a blank.

reply

It was when they were all in the back of a truck going to the Butcher and Matt wrestled one of them for a gun and shot the one who was driving.

reply

It was during My Roanoke Nightmare.

reply

Bloody hell. I;m having a total memory blank, and I dont even smoke weed.

Thanks my friend. Getting ready for xmas? How's the climate over your way?

reply

Yeah my family is getting together and Saturday for Christmas like every year so it should be fun. The weather is pretty cold but warmer than last year. Just cloudy. How about you?

reply

Breakfast with two of my brothers and their families then lunch with mother in law. Stinking hot here so I'm hoping for a cold lunch, but alas, it will be traditional english stodge. I'll just have to grab a bottle of french champagne and a straw.

reply

That sounds fun (except for the weather).

reply

It's quite nice today. Overcast and not too humid. Xmas day will be 27C and windy. Urghh.

reply