MovieChat Forums > 13 Reasons Why (2017) Discussion > In response to those who think Hannah ov...

In response to those who think Hannah overreacted about everything


This is an article that explains the teenage brain using neuroscience. (not totally sure how to do links here)

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/life/parenting/drama-queens-whats-really-going-on-in-a-teenage-girls-head/article28549947/

If TL;DR
'Updates to the limbic system heighten the brain’s emotional reactions with research indicating that the feeling centres beneath the cortex are actually more sensitive in teens than in children or adults. For example, one straightforward study used functional magnetic resonance imaging to watch teenage brains respond, in real time, to emotional input. The research team showed images of fearful, happy and calm faces to children, teens and adults while monitoring the activity of the amygdala, a key player in the emotional reactions of the limbic system. Compared to the brain activity of children and adults, the teens’ amygdalas reacted strongly to fearful or happy faces. In other words, emotional input rings like a gong for teenagers and a chime for everyone else.'

This explains why the nicest butt was such an issue for Hannah. Now obviously everyone's brains and brain development are not exactly the same and there are other things to contend with. But I don't find Hannah's reactions all that uncommon. There was another post that commented that they took the mental illness aspect away from the suicide, but I will counter, who in high school knows that their friend may be mentally ill? Depression has many facets.

No, Hannah is not the most sympathetic character, nor do I think that she was meant to be.

This is an older study that was done on the development of the brain and also includes hormones, puberty, neuroscience, and external circumstances. http://www.mdedge.com/currentpsychiatry/article/62670/teen-girl-brain-high-drama-high-risk-depression

reply

Plus there were a lot of worse things happened because of the list. She was hurt by Jessica and Alex, but their friendship was probably not beyond repair at that stage. Slapping her in Monet's was a big deal because even though drunken Jessica apologized later, it destroyed an outlet where she felt safe to vent. Hannah was always looking for real friends because she (and most everyone, especially teenagers) needed those people in her life that she could work out her problems with, and also she needed to be able to help the people she cared about with their problems. What makes the story so tragic is that she still had people who care about her that she could go to, but she was no longer able to trust anyone enough to open up.

reply

Ironically, all you have to do is read all the messages by trolls on social media ridiculing Hannah to know she didn't overreact.

reply