MovieChat Forums > Annie (2014) Discussion > Why is this rated so low?

Why is this rated so low?


I hate musicals, but I was bored on Netflix and decided to watch Annie because of the cast. I've seen the original Annie but I was never super passionate about it. Knew a couple songs and that was basically it. I just finished watching this one and I thought it was a nice movie. Unrealistic scenes (why would the fake parents keep on driving?) sure, but it's a kids movie. It was enjoyable and this is one of the first movies where I actually listened to all the songs. Loved it :D

reply

You get one guess.

It was rated low because a lot of people who didn't see it gave it a 1.
Its a common pattern for certain types of movies. You can see it by looking at the vote distribution:

http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1823664/ratings

9 times out of 10, when the 1 votes are at least ~3x more than the 2 votes the movie also has minorities in most of the lead roles. Especially if you break out the votes by male versus female.

Its not 100%. Some movies legitimately polarize viewers. And as more people vote the effect is usually mitigated because there just aren't enough dedicated bigots. This movie is a little bit of an exception in that 26,250 votes is pretty large already.

It will be interesting to come back in a year and see how the rating has changed. Here's a current snapshot for posterity:


26250 IMDb users have given a weighted average vote of 5.3 / 10

Demographic breakdowns are shown below.
Votes Percentage Rating
4130 15.7% 10
1213 4.6% 9
2183 8.3% 8
3409 13.0% 7
4160 15.8% 6
3425 13.0% 5
2054 7.8% 4
1403 5.3% 3
1069 4.1% 2
3204 12.2% 1

Arithmetic mean = 5.8. Median = 6

reply

So then by your logic, some voters gave this film a 10 just because it had a minority cast. I don't think anyone would believe that many people who actually saw this movie thought this was the best film they've ever seen. It goes both ways.

reply

You hate musicals but love this crap? Makes sense.

reply