Punishing


Maybe it's because I live in California and every now and then someone talks about the next "big" one, but I found this to be one of the most frightening movies I've ever seen. It evoked feeling of fear, disgust, despair, horror, apathy, a desire to lay down in defeat, depression, anxiety, hopelessness, panic --

Wow! What an excellent movie experience. Good job. Not something I'll ever watch again (except to see other people's reactions) but damn, I am physically shaken -- and I feel life in a new way -- MY life -- has more meaning. I feel refreshed and ready to LIVE.

For all of its faults (and it certainly has a lot of them) it left me in a pile of extreme mixed emotions. What other film does this to you? I have watched a lot of horror/disater films and this one takes the cake. Holy cow!

I gave it a 7/10 (I almost want to give it an 8) because it's not a truly GREAT film, but the sheer volume of emotions it created is something that not many films have achieved.

reply

Yeah the first impression I got from this movie was that it was not meant to be fun in the slightest. Where typical horror movies keep you entertained and amused this one came off as just plain discomforting. Maybe their motive in making this movie was not entertainment/fun but perhaps a message of worldly awareness of what's really out there and the extent of just what kind of tragedies can happen.

reply

I believe that really is the message and, although not directed by Eli Roth, it certainly is the message he most strongly emphasizes in his movies. Green Inferno, for example, Roth said as much, almost word for word -- he wants "people walking out of theaters" and "starring at the backs of their hands".

But I've watched a lot of gorey exploitation films, and I'm right there with Stephen King in his admiration for this new level of realistic horror -- so I don't get shocked so much by the graphic depictions of violence, so much as the realistic portrayal of human misery and horror. It's the combination of human emotion and realistic gore that's the kicker.

Nicolas Lopez, the Chilean director, will be directing the sequel to Roth's Green Inferno. Surely he is worthy of being included in the splat pack.

reply

***SPOILERS FOR THOSE WHO HAVEN'T SEEN THE MOVIE***



Yes! Thank you for saying this. I felt the same way once the movie was over. I'm sitting here shaking, and a little sick to my stomach. To be honest, I liked all of the characters. They weren't perfect, but they were human, and had many redeeming qualities. To be honest, while I was horrified by all of their deaths, I think the one that bothered me the most was the cleaning lady. She essentially saved their lives by finding a way out, and she is killed immediately in just a most horrific way.

Eli Roth certainly didn't shy away from the blood and gore. I expected a disaster film, but this goes beyond that. This felt real in so many ways, and it disturbed me on a profound level. I certainly will not watch it again, and I may not sleep tonight.



------------------------------

-= J =-

reply

Fellow Californian here, and yeah, this movie really freaked me out. I finished the movie over an hour ago and I've just been sitting alone in a room trying to come to grips with what I just watched. My heart was racing throughout the movie and it's still pumping! Also experiencing the shaking and mild nausea described by pastorjwallen! I usually love disaster flicks, but this one shook me (accidental pun!) more than any other I've ever seen. Ditto on never watching it again. I won't need to. This one will stick with me for a long time to come.

What I love about disaster flicks is that they make me think about how I would handle survival situations. Would I help a stranger in need even if it might put me in danger? Would I be willing to put my life before anyone else's? What about when society breaks down and it becomes every-man-for-himself? Would I be able to defend myself against the people that want what I have (or worse, those that would come after me like we see in this film)? Would I be the mother we see in the movie who is unwilling to make any exception letting somebody onto my street? Would I shoot somebody trying to come in even if I'm not sure that they're actually dangerous? It all urges me to set up an emergency plan for what to do in the event of a natural disaster or social breakdown, come up with an evacuation plan and a shelter-in-place plan. If some kind of disaster happened, far too few people are at all prepared, and those who are prepared can too easily become targets... Disaster flicks can really get you thinking about your own survival!

reply

Well said! I've actually put together an earthquake survival plan, in the event of such a disaster. Of course, I live out here in Ohio, and we don't get many earthquakes. That being said, we're close to the New Madrid fault line, which likes to catch everyone off guard every once in a while. Regardless, paranoia up a notch on that one!

------------------------------

-= J =-

reply