MovieChat Forums > Silent House (2012) Discussion > LOL i gave up when they went back...

LOL i gave up when they went back...

posted 12 years ago by twassell
4 replies | jump to latest

When she finally made it out of the house through the basement, and began running away down the road. This is when she saw the girl I think, and then "Uncle Peter" shows up.
I saw it coming a mile away that he would take her back to the house, and for some reason she goes along.... lol. Yeah she argued a little but just gave in. Any person in their right mind, would say look either you take me to the police now, or im getting out and walking, but theres no way in hell im going back into that house to look for my dead dad. "we have to find your dad we will be fine just stay with me..." so dumb, its like really?
Did anyone else find this to be so retarded that they stopped watching it there like me? To me the entire movie became invalid for being so stupid because of this.

[–] dbeuken 12 years ago

You are missing the point of the movie. She' s not trying to escape from the house. She's trying to escape from her memories by killing her father and uncle.

[–] cpheonix 12 years ago

And if the OP watched till the end they would have discovered this for themselves. At first I was outraged by his common cliche but stuck with it and it all made sense afterwards.

Lesson is: don't bash a film until you see all of it. Granted it is a mediocre film but at least this scene made sense now...

[–] GuyYouWishYouWere 12 years ago

I swear to god I knew NOTHING about this film going in(except that is was shot in one continuous take) and I predicted everything!!!

I mean everything!!!!

I said "that other girl isn't real"
I said "Her uncle molested her when she was younger"
I said "She is the one who's doing this"

Does that make me REALLY smart....Or...Is this movie REALLY dumb?

You tell me.

"See it with someone you love...Go by yourself"

[–] Xcstacy 12 years ago

This movie wasn't "dumb", however, it was a remake and a story that has been used before. It had nothing unique in the sense of plot twist or originality so ease your mind there champ, you're not smart.

~XTC