MovieChat Forums > The Revenant (2016) Discussion > I'm confused by the hate for this film.

I'm confused by the hate for this film.


I thought it was beautiful and I've seen it 4 times. It keeps getting better. I've read that many complain that it's so bleak, but that's the point. And there are moments that aren't bleak, where desperate men are out only for themselves such as scene with the helpful Indian, the scene where the boy gives food to the Indian woman in the shattered village, etc.

I love this film.

There seems to be no middle ground on this one. You either love it, or hate it. Strange. Why is that I wonder?

Edit: Weeks after posting this question, I've come to the conclusion that IMDB forums are full of a few thoughtful people and a bunch of goofballs. There are a lot of really nasty and childish comments here. For those who actually thought about their answers - thank you. But I won't waste any more time here. I'll discuss movies with friends over a few beers.

reply

I think most hate would be because of Di Caprio's and his climate change rants at the Oscars that year

reply

Don't hate the movie, pretty good actually --- BUT not good enough for the Oscars it received

reply

Anyone who cuts open a horse during a blizzard, digs out his intestines and guts and crawls inside him to survive wins an Oscar hands down.. This movie is excellent and anyone who hates this movie is simply hating for the sake of doing so because this is an awesome movie no matter how you look at it

reply

I see, so doing something historically correct wins the Oscar every time --- I'll keep that in mind, NOT really about acting of that other crap

reply

I see, so doing something historically correct wins the Oscar every time --- I'll keep that in mind,

reply

Worked for Costner in JFK.. Dicaprio did some serious method acting and they stuff in this movie he had to endure was more than worthy of winning an Oscar..

reply

Yawn

reply

I didn't hate it. I liked it okay. Probably won't ever watch it again.

reply

I thought it was pretty good. Worth seeing once, but I won't bother to ever see it again.

reply