MovieChat Forums > My Week with Marilyn (2011) Discussion > Film was Doomed From the Start by the Ca...

Film was Doomed From the Start by the Casting of Marilyn


Williams manages to look like her somewhat and wiggle like her somewhat but what is missing is the charisma, the love affair that the camera had with Marilyn. I guess you can't blame the casting directors or producers because where were they going to find a woman with Marilyn's charisma?

The one thing this film did do is make me pull out my dvd of the real thing and enjoy it all over again.

Judi Dench was wonderful as Dame Sykes and Branaugh was great as Olivier. It was very true to life when he spoke, as Olivier, about being sad that he was getting old and couldn't do anything about it as I'm sure Branaugh feels the same way. Heck, we all do!

reply

MM's missing screen magic is definitely a spanner in the works. Here's an insightful quote from another IMDB poster:

Billy Wilder, who directed Marilyn Monroe twice (in The Seven Year Itch and Some Like It Hot) said that when you watched Monroe performing a scene, it was nothing, but when you saw her projected up on the screen it was indeed "magic": the camera caught something about her that wasn't evident in real life. Whatever this was, it's something that a number of stars, male and female, have had. It's not a talent that can be learned or applied, switched on and off. It's innate and unforced. People who have such a quality and are aware of it can build on it by learning how to best play to the camera, but you can't invent or feign it.

It's this "extra" that made Wilder decide to hire Marilyn for Some Like It Hot after his dreadful experiences with her on Itch. Her tardiness, lack of preparation and disregard for her fellow performers had so irritated Wilder (and everyone else) that he vowed never to work with her again. But she was the one actress really suited for the role. Her bad habits had grown vastly worse in the intervening four years, but in the end what he got on the screen was -- barely -- worth it. But once more he said he would never, ever work with her again. The fact that he and others were willing to put up with such nonsense is testament to that special something that Marilyn and no one else had.


__________
Last movie watched: My Week with Marilyn (6/10)

reply