MovieChat Forums > Million Dollar Arm (2014) Discussion > People bitching about elevator/escalator...

People bitching about elevator/escalator scenes


This movie isn't supposed to be representative of all Indians, just two rural boys who had never had much experience with technology. The fact is, the real Rinku Singh and Dinesh Patel had never before seen an elevator/escalator and were from backwater villages that had no Internet, flat-screen TVs or cell phones. The movie portrayed their experiences accurately, but it wasn't saying, "This is how all Indians are!"

You have to remember, India is a big country with the second-highest population in the world (1.2 billion). That's almost four times the USA's population (318 million). I don't know the exact statistics, but let's just say that 318 million Indians are as technologically advanced as the US, that still leaves roughly 882 million people without. That's nearly a billion people -- or just 139.5 million more than the entire population of Europe (742.5)!

Thus, it's not unreasonable that there are literally hundreds of millions of people in India who don't have access to modern technology, especially in a country with such poverty disparity as India.

But once again, let me reiterate, this movie is about the experiences of two dirt-poor boys from rustic India. It's not a critique nor a commentary about India as a whole.

P.S. Those who are arguing that they've met Indians who are technologically adept and have the latest gadgets, well, did you consider that they're also not representative of all Indians? In fact, the wealthy and middle class Indians are in the minority.


.

reply

Some are from rural parts of the country but hey the Hollywood version wanted to basically exaggerate on it.

Like the 80's movie "Big" with Tom Hanks. The Giant piano on the floor.
I still haven't been on that, nor went to Disney World. So there are things in the world not everyone has experienced.

Example" Have you tried a Mango Lassi in India?
Unless you been to India?
I'm South Asian and I haven't been to India.

reply

When the US was bringing over the 'lost boys' from Africa (child soldiers), some came to Atlanta. They had to be shown how to operate a door, and water faucets. The basics! But if you haven't seen these things before, they would be like magic to you. Even a doorknob! This is a modern, complex country. But if we were dropped into rural Africa, it would take us time to learn how things worked.
And if you weren't born into the computer world, everything about it may still feel a bit like FM! (F'in Magic)

reply

LOL I thought the joke is that they expected the up escalator to be on the left!

reply