MovieChat Forums > Ancient Aliens (2009) Discussion > Dumb! Debunked, and full of lies

Dumb! Debunked, and full of lies


This show is so stupid. Everyone needs to read Jason Colavito's blog and reviews of the shows outright lies, fantasy's and deceit. Also watch Ancient Aliens debunked for more on how stupid this show is

reply

This show is so stupid.


No, the show is not stupid.

It is YOUR interpretation of what the show is presenting that is stupid. You obviously DON'T understand what THEORY means. Look up "THEORY" in an encyclopedia sometime. Don't listen to what some Armchair Blogger says it is.


Everyone needs to read Jason Colavito's blog and reviews of the shows outright lies, fantasy's and deceit.


Who the heck is Jason Colavito? and why should I believe his Armchair Blogging nonsense?


Also watch Ancient Aliens debunked for more on how stupid this show is


Just like this show highly suggests that one group's THEORY believes that ALIENS visited our ancient past...

Other shows try to show the other side of the THEORY coin that ALIENS did NOT visit our ancient past...

I'm not saying that ALIENS have never visited our planet. I wasn't there, so I can't say YAY or NAY. However...

Personally, I believe that Modern Humans have been on our planet far longer than Mainstream Historians believe, and that some older cultures developed advanced technologies which allowed them to build many of these megalithic structure on this planet. And that over time, these cultures died off, or were destroyed. THEN all records of who they were, and their collective knowledge was lost. Only their mysterious structure remain.

Many people won't accept that there are many megalithic structure on this planet that predate mainstream historical beliefs, and yet... There are there for YOU to go and see for YOURSELF! If people won't believe in that, that they won't believe in a group of people which historical records don't acknowledge.

I bet this Jason Colavito hasn't left his parents basement to see these megalithic structures... So again, Why should I believe him?



NOW, Stop TROLLING this forum. We get that you DON'T believe in ALIENS, and therefore, obviously believe that the show's THEORY about ALIENS building these megalithic structures is nonsense.

BUT the FACT remains, that these Megalithic Structures DO EXIST, and they had to have built by SOMEONE. Mainstream Historians claim that Modern Humans did not exist during the Last Ice Age. And If That Is TRUE...

WHO BUILT THEM?

In Really, that is all that this show is trying to figure out.

Don't take the THEORY that is was ALIENS so seriously!



"Put A Little Love In Your Heart, and then Make Your Own Kind Of Music, on the road to Shambala!"

reply

Danny Dier called, he wants his brain cell back

I'm Brian and so is my wife!

reply

Danny Dier called, he wants his brain cell back


Who's Danny Dier?


And are you talking to me?

If you are insulting ME...

Then I guess that you don't believe in the Egyptian Pyramids? Physical Objects that have been photographed, which you or I can go see. Just like MANY of the other places featured on Ancient Aliens.

According to Mainstream Historians and Archaeologists. Mankind was living in caves and munching on bananas, and did not have the brainpower or the tools to build them. So if mankind didn't build them, they why don't YOU tell me who did... Mr. Genius!

The Ancient Alien THEORY only proposes that "Aliens" built them, in order to explain how these things exist.

Another possible THEORY, that I subscribe to, is that ancient HUMAN cultures existed further back in our history than we think, and built these places and were destroyed, and all information and knowledge of them were lost. Much like Atlantis.

Ever hear of the Library of Alexandria? It was one of the largest and most significant libraries of the ancient world. And it was completely destroyed by 642 AD. That was 1374 Years ago!. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_of_Alexandria. Who knows what information and knowledge was kept there and lost to time.

It wouldn't be the first time this would happen. Remember the Dark Ages & the Salem Witch Trials? Periods of time where anything was different was destroyed. Even in WWII, the NAZIs burnt all kinds of books... And killed many of their owners. Who knows what was lost then too.


I tell you, some of you folks on IMDb, leave me completely mind boggled. You are so CLOSE MINDED, that you can't set aside the "ALIEN" stuff part of this show, and realize that our history is inaccurate and incomplete, and there is a ton of archaeological sites that proves that!

Insult ME all you want, but those megalithic structures still exist, and long after I'm dead, YOU will still have to deal with the fact, that SOMEONE built them!

And don't even get me started about how people saw Rockets and Airplanes flying above them, centuries before the Wright brothers flew their propeller driven canvas covered wooden glider in 1903...

reply

Mankind living in caves and munching on bananas...

Bananas are an exotic fruit, are you talking about Asia?
In that case, they did not live in caves around the time when the Pyramids were built.

Maybe you are talking about the people in Europe.
Even then, they were able to construct Stonehenge.

reply

He clearly stated that's what "Mainstream historians and archaeologists" have suggested.

Ask them.

reply

Thank You.

I said that right before the statement he quoted.

I guess too many people don't know how to read properly, or refuse to see what is right in front of them...



Look, All I am trying to say here is this...

Religions state that Man was created by God at a certain date... AND...
Mainstream historians and archaeologists claim that Modern Man didn't show up until a certain date.

Now we are finding the megalithic structures all over the world that PREDATES those dates.

SOMEONE... had to build them.

That means that either... Religions, and/or Mainstream historians and archaeologists are WRONG...

OR...

Time Travelers and/or Aliens had to build them.

If anyone has a fifth THEORY, please share!

If you don't believe that Aliens did it... FINE... But, at least turn this constant arguing, with insults and hatred... into a debate, by telling us your opinions on who made these things...

I already have. I said it was a HUMAN civilization that developed knowledge and technology who was "destroyed" and all evidence of them was lost in time, or is buried under Volcanic Rock, Desert Sand, Glaciers, or Oceans...


"Put A Little Love In Your Heart, and then Make Your Own Kind Of Music, on the road to Shambala!"

reply

Well ok, my bad.
I just find some of your posts very aversive to read, i guess i should try harder when i want to respond.
Because we did meet common ground before, i just thought you were shouty and sorta flying off the handle, but i misinterpreted that, which caused me to skim the comment.

But yeah, i also think the historic structures would be attributed to ancient human civilizations, and i do not care if mainstream scientists or archeologists are wrong now, theyll figure it out at some point.

And as much as i like Science-Fiction, i just dont believe that the Ancient Alien theory is very credible. I do like comparing it to religion, but to say that those stories are based on facts, meh, it just doesnt add up.
But i dont exclude the possibility, as with religion, nobody knows THE answer, but i dont particularly like what they did with the ideas so far, which causes me to be very reserved with my convictions, but still to have strong opinions, to hopefully find a satisfactory answer.

reply

Oh, my mistake. There is no longer a brain cell to give back.

I'm Brian and so is my wife!

reply

Ive stopped here:

You obviously DON'T understand what THEORY means.

...and obviously you dont either and you dont understand what hard facts means as well.
Let me explain it to you...
Theory is used on things that have nor yet being explained... and not when something its already exploited, explained and proved beyond any shadow of doubt.

They have not the tiniest indication (let alone evidence) for the BS that they say and on the contrary we have mountains of evidence on how things really happened.

So if an idiot comes up tomorrow with a theory that the sun is cold, we should accept it as "just a theory" ? No, he is an idiot cause his theory doesnt makes sense nor ever will, like the idiotic theories of the idiotic people in this show.

What they say in this show is 100% BS that they have pulled out of their irrational, paranoid, delusional and idiotic bottoms, period. Get over it.

reply

...and obviously you don't either and you don't understand what hard facts means as well.

Let me explain it to you...

Theory is used on things that have nor yet being explained... and not when something its already exploited, explained and proved beyond any shadow of doubt.


Oh... right... Your argument makes no sense. You're talking in circles!

So, What has been proved as FACT in this show? According to the history books, Humans didn't build some of these megalithic structures. So Who Did? The show "THEORIZES" that Aliens did it. Something which has yet to be proven as FACT.

I DO understand the difference between THEORY and FACT!

YOU clearly misunderstood what I was talking about!

They have not the tiniest indication (let alone evidence) for the BS that they say and on the contrary we have mountains of evidence on how things really happened.


What "evidence"? There is not ONE piece of "evidence" that indicates who built these 10000 year old Ancient Megalithic Structures, let alone a mountain of it. There are no bones. There are no tools. There are no inscriptions. There are no written records stating who built them. Nothing. Just some megalithic structures sitting there that are NOT natural formations.

The ONLY FACTS this show presents the viewers, is that there are megalithic structure on our planet that date to before 5000 BC. According to the historians and the history books, Mankind did not start building anything until about 5000 BC, at the earliest. So, Who built these structures that date back to 10,000 BC? Someone had to! Since historians won't admit that they are wrong about humans existing before 5000 BC... The Ancient Alien "Theory" proposes that Aliens did it, which has yet to be "Proven".

No one knows what really happened. If we did, we would not be here arguing about it...

Personally, I think our history books are wrong, and that Humans have been around on this planet far longer...

If you have another "THEORY" in mind, as to who built these structures, please tell me what that is...

So if an idiot comes up tomorrow with a theory that the sun is cold, we should accept it as "just a theory"?


Yes!

A Theory is NOT fact. A Theory is NOT true. It is a hypothesis. Hypotheses must be tested before it can be a FACT. Example. I have a theory that 1 + 2 = 3. I test it with a calculator. A standard device, accepted by the human race, as tool for measuring math formulas. Guess What? 1 + 2 DID IN FACT = 3. My THEORY is NOW Fact.

The show does NOT talk about the Ancient Alien "FACT", why? because it has yet to be proven true.


No, he is an idiot because his theory doesn't makes sense nor ever will


POOR ARGUMENT, Because...

What if a thermometer were used to show the Sun is a colder than a block of ICE?

However, we have already tested the Sun with thermometer, and it does show it is not Cold, It is very HOT!

Some guy, now, theorizing that sun is cold, would be an idiot, because we know, as shown time and time again, that testing it with another thermometer would show it to be hot. His theory would not be true... "Not FACT".


like the idiotic theories of the idiotic people in this show.


The theories presented on this show are NOT idiotic, because no one has proven who built the 10000 year old megalithic structures. Since or history books claim that Mankind did not, and some one had to have built them... ALIENS very well could have. That is the theory this show is claiming. But nothing has been proven as true or as fact yet.

As I said, for all we know, our history books may be wrong. Carbon Dating is not 100% reliable. And any written dates, prior to the Birth Of Christ, is pure speculation, or THEORY, as well. No one knew when Christ would be born... When the Pyramids were (Supposedly) built, No one knew that it 2500 BC! Historians just claim that it was built during the time of Khufu (I Think)... Whenever that actually was... And now, we are finding that Khufu may not have built it anyway... So who knows?

What they say in this show is 100% BS that they have pulled out of their irrational, paranoid, delusional and idiotic bottoms, period.


Nothing has been proven as to who built these megalithic structures, and who was flying "jets" before the Wright brothers flew their Propeller driven glider in 1903...

Maybe it was Aliens, Maybe it was humans, Maybe it was witches...

The show is not 100% BS, because it may very well be true. I will admit thought, that MUCH of what they talk about is questionable. But BS, NO!

Get over it.


I am quite open minded as to whatever the truth is or facts are, as to what archaeology presents to us. I want to know.

Are You Open Minded? Do You Want To Know the Truth?

It seems people like you are not open minded to believing in something other than what they currently believe in?

What is that by the way?

You're the ones who won't "Get over it" and keep coming here stating YOUR THEORIES, about how this show is 100% BS, without providing any evidence, to prove anything True or Factual..

Our history books STATE that it isn't humans. Most people don't believe that some magical "God" created the Earth 5000 years ago with a snap of his fingers... The old argument for that? The "Aged Universe THEORY"? ALL EVIDENCE points that that THEORY being a bunch of BS, and is NOT TRUE and NOT FACT.

The most likely answer then, is... ALIENS.

BUT WAIT! YOU don't believe in Aliens...



I have said time and time again, that I don't think that it was Aliens, or at least not ALL of it. I think our Historians, and History books are wrong! HUMANS built most of them, and they were destroyed. (Possibly by Noah's Flood?)

That's my THEORY. Which I can't prove true or as fact. WHY? I have no evidence. Archaeologists don't have any evidence either. There are no bones. There are no tools. There are no inscriptions. There are no written records stating who built them. Nothing. Just some megalithic structures sitting there that are NOT natural formations.

It is more likely that Aliens built them, and left, and took their tools with them. Yes, that might sound like 100% BS, but it isn't! Both theories are equally possible. It can only be 50% BS at BEST! Add other THEORIES to the mix and the percentage drops!

Until some evidence is found to support either THEORY, that is all that they will ever be. THEORY. It can't be TRUE or FACT, because it can't be proven.



NOW, I will ask YOU, and everyone else here, ONE MORE F'ING TIME...

WHO do YOU think built these 10000 year old Ancient Megalithic Structures?

reply

I have a theory that some of the people that post here (for the sake of argument we'll call them trolls) only post here to try to get a rise out of anyone who posts saying that they're open to the possibility that AA theory can't logically and/or rationally be totally dismissed.

That theory is based on the fact that there are many people who's bravery is based solely on them being part of a majority. Period.

Those trolls can be identified by the fact that they invariably resort to calling anyone who disagrees with the majority opinion delusional, irrational, etc...because you know...a majority has never been proven wrong. [cough]The Nazis[cough]





reply

Oh... right... Your argument makes no sense. You're talking in circles!
Yes it does but apparently you are incapable to understand it, even tho that is extremely simple.

So, What has been proved as FACT in this show? According to the history books, Humans didn't build
Yeah ok sure what ever you pulled that out of thin air and like this show you have absolutely NOTHING to back up this.

Also if you expect anyone or me to read that long @ss post, especially after starting with nonsense like that, there is somethign terribly wrong with you.period.

reply

Let me explain it to you...

Theory is used on things that have not yet being explained... and not when something its already exploited, explained and proved beyond any shadow of doubt

Oh... right... Your argument makes no sense. You're talking in circles!

Yes it does but apparently you are incapable to understand it, even tho that is extremely simple


NOTHING has been explained and "proved beyond any shadow of doubt" as to who built the the 10000 year old Ancient Megalithic Structures, because... there are no bones. There are no tools. There are no inscriptions. There are no written records stating who built them. Nothing. No Evidence of Any Kind.

Maybe it was God, Maybe it was Humans, Maybe it was Aliens, Maybe it was Time Travelers... Heck, Maybe it was Witches... No matter what I say I think it is, I have no evidence to "prove beyond any shadow of doubt" that my hypothesis is True or Fact, so it remains... A THEORY!

The show only hypothesizes that it was ALIENS, with their unproven THEORY, because the Bible and History Books STATE that it was NOT Mankind. Someone else had to build them them... No one has PROVEN that the Bible and History Books are WRONG and that it WAS Mankind. So it must have been Aliens then. I can't think of anyone else...CAN YOU?

whatever you pulled that out of thin air and like this show you have absolutely NOTHING to back up this.


So the Bibles in churches, and history books being used to teach children in schools, is NOT Evidence? Then what is? Both the Bible and History Books, state that mankind was not building megalithic structures 10000 years ago.

By the way, I didn't pull the Bible and History Books of "thin air" to support my opinion... They existed before I was born, and before YOU were born, AND YOU KNOW IT! I'm not saying either you or I agree with what they state, but they are generally "considered" to be FACT by the majority of the population. At least that is what my parents and teachers told me, WHY?, because that is what they believed, and what their parents and teachers believed and so on...

However, now many things in the Bible and History Books are being proven to be FALSE...

especially after starting with nonsense like that


It wasn't nonsense. And I can't understand why you can't see that.

if you expect anyone or me to read that long post


Maybe that's your problem. You refuse to read anything that tries to explain things to you. The last time I looked, Both the Bible and History Books, have far more pages and words, than what I posted. 5000 years of history can't be told in a twitter post you twit. It requires long posts.



One last thing... I see that you did not answer my question...

WHO do YOU think built these 10000 year old Ancient Megalithic Structures?

Continuing to NOT answer my question, just tells me that you are nothing but a TROLL...

GOOD DAY.

reply

Ok now I've stopped here...

No one has PROVEN that the Bible and History Books are WRONG

You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about, you have complete and utter ignorance.
Its a fact beyond any doubt that the bible is wrong/false in every-single-thing, and we know again beyond any doubt that its a work of fiction.

No one has proven history books wrong? oh dear...
Herodotus writings alone are more than enough to prove that. We know (again) beyond any doubt that he has done many mistakes and way too many exaggerations.

Also we havent proven that Superman, Batman, Spiderman etc etc are real... lets get a show with dumb theories about it.

So again, you have absolutely no idea what you are talking about and obviously thats the reason why you believe this BS show and the wackos that present it.

reply

You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about, you have complete and utter ignorance.


Wrong.

It's a fact beyond any doubt that the bible is wrong/false in every-single-thing, and we know again beyond any doubt that it' s a work of fiction


"Cain killed his brother Abel."

Prove to me that there was no Cain. There was no Abel. and Cain did not kill his brother Abel... No one has proven this story false.

The bible is a collection of "stories", like this one, from documents like the Dead Sea Scrolls. Most of those stories are what is in the bible, and most have NOT been proven to be false. There is NO reason to believe they are NOT true.

If you don't believe in God. Fine. You have that right. I don't either.

Personally, I agree, that the Bible is MOSTLY nonsense....

Even though the bible says that, "God sent a great flood to wipe out mankind around 3000 BC", I agree with the show, when it says that it was a natural disaster that brought an end to the ice age, ocean levels rose, and all that water from melting ice flowed into flood plains all over the world, killing the majority of people who lived there. The survivors wanted answers as to what happened to them, and the only answer they could come up with was that God was punishing them. All because they did not know what a Flood Plain was, and how Floods work... IT IS NOT POSSIBLE FOR EVERYTHING ON THIS PLANET, INCLUDING MOUNT EVEREST TO BE UNDERWATER. EVEN WITH 40 DAYS AND 40 NIGHT OF RAIN. ...Evidence is now showing that the Bible is wrong. "Noah's" Flood is FALSE. "ICE Age" flood is TRUE. I don't know what to think about the part about "Noah Building A Boat." Maybe some guy named Noah, did build a boat...

...But I don't believe it is all fiction.

Let's just agree to disagree that God doesn't exist, and the bible is fiction.

FACT 1.) God did NOT built the 10000 year old ancient megalithic structures, as part of his "AGED" Universe ploy.


No one has proven history books wrong?


You're stretching things here...

I said, history books state that "MANKIND was not able to build ancient megalithic structures, 10000 years ago."

NO ONE has proven that statement to be wrong. At least not yet.

So for now...

Hypothetical "FACT" 2.) Mankind did NOT built the 10000 year old ancient megalithic structures.

Obviously that's the reason why you believe this BS show and the wackos that present it


There nothing obvious going on here...

Do you know what the funniest thing about YOU is? Basically, You are arguing with me about the fact that, I AGREE WITH YOU...

I don't believe that everything that this show presents was done by "Aliens".


ALL I AM SAYING IS THIS...

FACT 1.) God did NOT built the 10000 year old ancient megalithic structures, as part of his "AGED" Universe ploy.

and History Books state:

Hypothetical "FACT" 2.) Mankind did NOT built the 10000 year old ancient megalithic structures.

So, only Aliens, Time Travelers, or "Witches" could have built the 10000 year old ancient megalithic structures.

The most likely of these scenarios is, that Aliens built them.

This show only THEORIZES, that Aliens built these these 10000 year old ancient megalithic structures, as a means to explain them.... BECAUSE MANKIND "DID NOT" BUILD THEM.

Not Fact: "DID NOT", but Hypothetical: "DID NOT".


THEORY: "a proposed explanation whose status is still conjectural and subject to experimentation, in contrast to well-established propositions that are regarded as reporting matters of actual fact."

Synonyms: idea, notion hypothesis, postulate.

http://www.dictionary.com/browse/theory?s=t


Could ALIENS have built these 10000 year old ancient megalithic structures? SURE. But NO ONE has proven that ALIENS actually did. It is not FACT. Remember the show always says "What IF it were True?" The show just brings these mysterious structure to our attention, in hopes that they can be explained.

Lighten Up. Don't take it so seriously... It is NOT an attack on your beliefs.


At this moment, I believe the history books are WRONG, and that ALIENS did NOT build them. Mankind built them. However, I still have questions about that. I look to the show for POSSIBLE answers. Hopefully someday, we will know what really happened.

I would love to know who was flying around in airplanes and jets, centuries ago, and why that never made it into the history books!


As for much of the rest of the show, I agree with that much of it is BS. I don't believe that aliens communicated with Tesla, Einstein, and so on. I believe that episodes like that just made for filler and entertainment. Keyword: ENTERTAINMENT.

reply

Stop making long post i dont even bother reading them cause from the get-go you are saying completely irrational things... like

Prove to me that there was no Cain. There was no Abel. and Cain did not kill his brother Abel... No one has proven this story false.


This is the most, the utter, the supreme idiotic argument ever made.
Only ignorant - uneducated people bring that argument up, period.
Its the battle-cry argument of the any-BS "theoriests".
What you are actually saying there is"
"I have pulled everything out of my bottom, I have 0 evidence, proofs, not even indication and its my last stand to dumb you down".

Well sorry but NO i wont get to that loop and let me clear something up for you...
For every dumb story that a every crazy person pulls out of him bottom you cant ask from another person proofs, thats not how science work.

The person that makes the claims must and have to present the proofs, not the other way around... and thats also how the COURTS OF LAW work!
You need proofs and evidence to get someone in jail, not the lack of it.

I claim that I haven NOT been abducted by aliens, now prove to me that I HAVE?

....and to push it to the edge... Can you prove to me that you are NOT a pedophile? can you? No you cant, so you are a pedophile.

Do you have any evidence or even indications to back up your claims? any valid arguments? No? No? Go home then and when you do we can talk again.

I am done with you, people that use this utter idiotic argument arent worthy discussing and by using that argument alone PROVES that you do NOT understand science, data, evidence, proofs, indications, research AT ALL!

Like I've said and you prove it in every post, You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about, you have complete ignorance and thats why the BS that these idiots say in this show makes sense to you.




reply

This is the most, the utter, the supreme idiotic argument ever made.

No one has proven that the Ancient Alien Theory is false.
No one has proven that the Ancient Alien Theory is true.

It's a 50/50% chance, that it was true, or that it was false. Whichever belief other people have, they have the same chance to be right or wrong. Using it as an argument is not idiotic. Many people believe in Aliens. Just because you don't believe in them, that does not mean that you are right.

The person that makes the claims must and have to present the proofs, not the other way around... and that's also how the COURTS OF LAW work!

You are claiming that Aliens were NOT on our planet. There is 50% percent chance that they were. You have not proven to me that Aliens were NOT on our planet. You saying that: "Aliens Don't Exist", is not evidence.

History Books, which are accepted as fact by our society, the same society that runs the courts, would be upheld in a COURT OF LAW, because no one has proven them wrong. They state: mankind did not build the 10000 year old megalithic structures. So, who built them?

Do you have any evidence or even indications to back up your claims? any valid arguments? No? No? Go home then and when you do we can talk again.

The pot calling the kettle black...

people that use this utter idiotic argument aren't worthy discussing and by using that argument alone PROVES that you do NOT understand science, data, evidence, proofs, indications, research AT ALL!

Neither do you. You have not proven to anyone that Aliens were NOT on our planet, or that mankind was building 10000 year old megalithic structures. All you do is keep arguing with, and insulting other people, Who may be correct, for suggesting the possibility, that Aliens were here.

Actually, according to statistics, and proof from space telescopes that there are other planets outside of our solar system. Scientists are now saying there must Alien life, somewhere, in the universe! Even the the Church has admitted that believing in aliens does not violate religion.

You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about, You have complete ignorance and that's why the BS that these idiots say in this show makes sense to you.

1.) You have provided NO proof, that the Ancient Alien Theory is a lie...
2.) You have provided NO proof, that the history books, and archaeologists are wrong, and that mankind built 10000 year old megalithic structures...
3.) I have an equal chance, 50/50, that whichever one of these theories I believe in is correct, AND I HAVE THAT RIGHT, and still you keep insulting me and calling me names, instead of trying to convince me to change my mind, assuming that you and I don't agree as to what that is... By providing me with hard evidence to support YOUR theory...
4.) I have asked you several times to provide, an alternative theory as to what happened in our ancient past. You have Not.

The only thing that I can concluded is that, you are just a Troll, and you are trying to infuriate me.

I am done with you.

I see no reason to argue with you on that one, since I have no idea where you are coming from, and you are refusing to enlighten me on what that may be. I have tried to tell you where I am coming from, but you refuse to "read" or listen...

mcdemuth... DOESN'T BELIEVE IT WAS ALIENS!!! But I can't prove that, and I can't prove that it was mankind either.

If you would like to start sharing your theories, and evidence to support... "whatever they are", I will be more than willing to listen. Until Then...

Good Day.

reply

[deleted]

Let's Try This...



Under these conditions, and "Facts".

1.) Once upon a time people thought, God created an "AGED" Earth around 5000 BC... But nobody believes that anymore. Why? Because the archaeological and geological evidence shows the Earth is at least 4.5 billion years old.

SO, It can't be GOD... and YOU don't believe in GOD or religions in anyway.

2.) Mainstream Historians and History Books currently state that mankind was not capable of building Megalithic Structures, 10000 Years ago. This belief has not been proven to be FALSE, because... There is no evidence or documentation to show that mankind was ever at those locations at that time, and there is no evidence or documentation to show that Mankind had the brainpower and the knowledge to be capable of building them.

So, for now, It must be true, that Mankind did not build them.


The show, Ancient Aliens, agrees with those "facts". And now asks you to take this test...

Who Built The 10000 Year Old Megalithic Structures?

A.) God.

B.) Mankind.

C.) Aliens.

D.) Something Else. Please Specify:




When I take the test, here is what I believe...

I think someday, the History Books will be proven WRONG, and Mankind will be a legitimate answer. But... Since I am being told by society right now that it can't be... And since I can't think of what else it could be for answer (D)...

I guess, the only answer that I can pick at this time... would be C.)

That is what the show "Ancient Aliens" is saying is the correct answer. That is not BS, it just makes perfect sense.

However, there is NO proof that Aliens did in fact built them, because there are no Alien Corpses, or Spaceships, or Alien Tech that has been "found" that proves it to be true. It has not be proven to be false either. So, For now, it is just a THEORY. Strongly believed in by many people because, they believe that there is no other answer out there...



Is C.) the answer you picked?

IF you picked A.) or B.)... How can you? You should know that is a wrong answer. Everyone believes it is wrong. If it isn't, you better enlighten the WORLD quick... Show us your proof or evidence, so we can squash the Alien Theory into dust.

If you picked D.) Please tell me your Theory. I really want to know, because no other theories are being presented by anyone... It's time to add another one to the mix.

reply

So Einstein was an idiot too, omg, i didnt know that, he just came up with that his theory of relativity, OMG
also for u then in this line of thoughts every scientist is an idiot, cause if they come up with like cold fusion, omg hes and idiot, it cant exist, cant be done
what ure saying is the biggest BS
cause if ure not trying to invent things, we would be living in caves and searching for berries in woods, hunting with stone age weapons.
And the only written language we would know would be wall painting.
Theres always something somebodys inventing for the first time and ppl like you would always call that BS, cause they cant comprehend the fact its working.
Ure life must be hell, cause well everywhere u look at, u must be in disbelief.

reply

Clearly you are extremely stupid... Cause
A: Clearly you do not know how to read, cause if you could you wouldnt say this utters BS to me.

B: You legendary idiot, einstein and every scientist do NOT make theories upon things that we already know, or know how they work, or we have fully exploited.... and most importantly they make theories that are based or REASON not in BS, delusions and insanity.

For example,
A combustion engine runs cause of the combustion of a fuel... now if someone comes up with a theory that a combustion engine works cause elfs are running inside it, plain and simple he is dumb fking nutcase.

Thats exactly what the idiots in this show are doing, but obviously you are too fking stupid to even understand that simple thing.


Ure life must be hell, cause well everywhere u look at, u must be in disbelief.

Yeah sorry that I live with facts and reason and not with irrationality, delusions, stupidity and complete lack of education.





reply

Many people won't accept that there are many megalithic structure on this planet that predate mainstream historical beliefs, and yet... There are there for YOU to go and see for YOURSELF! If people won't believe in that, that they won't believe in a group of people which historical records don't acknowledge.

I bet this Jason Colavito hasn't left his parents basement to see these megalithic structures... So again, Why should I believe him?

---

Agreed, and maybe I got zapped in 1970 when I took a nap propped up against one of Kubrick's monoliths at Stonehenge, BUT one can't DO that anymore as it has been fenced off to all except Obama who was able to get Stonehenge "off my bucket list" as he said.

The MAIN potential advantage of AA to Americans is to make them THINK, which is an activity that threatens dem Eyes Wide Shut and takes them out of their comfort zone [as Night shows in his Village as well as Signs and The Happening].

So AA explores the exact same issues that Kubrick CONFIRMS were the matters of 2001 ASO, 'cept one is a doco and one is a "thinkpiece dressed up as a Yippee".

Americans are Carefully Taught [South Pacific 1959] to "take sides" on all issues so are totally out of their "Village" [espec since 9/11] if asked to watch, weigh up and make their OWN conclusions on issues, or as Brian said in Life of Brian "you have to work it out for yourselves".

The irony here is that IF you do that for the ape sequence in ASO - ie actually WATCH what Kubrick is saying then you will find that MoonWatcher worked out the exact day for the solar eclipse AND was way smarter than the "space bunnies" to follow.

The further irony is that was probably too hard for Georgie et al from AA to figure, for as good as AA is, it is just a bit too "Hollywood".

http://www.kindleflippages.com/ablog/

reply

Ancient Aliens questions the origins of modern day Christianity. The guy who made Ancient Aliens Debunked (Chris White) classifies himself as a Christian, and a Conservative Christian at that.

So White wasn't without his own motivation for coming up with a theory about AA in an effort to validate his personal religious belief, as Covalito somewhat conveniently only revealed near the end of his review of AAD.

Yesterday filmmaker Chris White released his new, three-hour documentary Ancient Aliens Debunked, which will be of interest to my readers since it is an exceptionally thorough examination of the specious claims made on the History/H2 series Ancient Aliens in the light of actual facts. The documentary goes through such claims as "impossible" megalithic architecture, "alien" images in art, and "extraterrestrials" in ancient texts and demolishes each with surgical precision. It doesn't hurt that the movie quotes me extensively at various points.

First, a bit of disclosure: Chris White asked me to participate in the documentary back in the spring, but our schedules did not mesh when he was filming. Despite the extensive use of my material in the sections on Arthur Posnansky, ancient atom bombs, and vimana aircraft, I was not involved in the production in any way and have not received any compensation from it. I did not see the film until its release yesterday.


....From a film perspective, a bit of background on the filmmaker--who narrates in the first person--would have been helpful. It isn't clear until near the end that he has something of a dog in this fight. White is a Christian (which I know because he told me so), and he has a Biblical perspective that leads him to propose, for example, that the flood of Noah really happened and that global myths are connected through one exceedingly ancient source (a la the Tower of Babel). This doesn't significantly impact the good work he does in his film (it's a very minor part of the story), but it would have been helpful to know two hours or so earlier. --- Jason Covalito


So from a review perspective, a bit of background on the reviewer would have been helpful since it would have revealed that Covalito also had a dog in the fight...seeing as how White simply echoed some of Covalitos disagreeing opinions about some of the things suggested in AA, which would explain why Covalito would try to downplay Whites religious beliefs at the end of his review as being a "minor part of the story".

It becomes a vicious cycle really.

reply

The only problem with Ancient Aliens Debunked is 3/4ths of the way through the guy goes off on a tangent about Bible accuracy and states how unquestionable it is, and ruins the whole documentary by doing EXACTLY what he accuses AA of doing.

Worst case of pot calling the kettle black ever in the history of mankind

reply

I give a thumbs up to Jason Colavito. He does a great job debunking the AA claim. While I'm open to the possibility of alien visitation, I think the evidence for ancient astronauts in my opinion, is not too convincing.

Go, Miami Redhawks!!!

reply

by lisasboyfriend » I give a thumbs up to Jason Colavito. He does a great job debunking the AA claim. While I'm open to the possibility of alien visitation, I think the evidence for ancient astronauts in my opinion, is not too convincing.

Thanks for sharing...your opinion...again.

Apparently you missed the part...again...earlier in this thread though where it's established that his great job of debunking wasn't in actuality so great/convincing.

reply

Apparently you missed the part...again...earlier in this thread though where it's established that his great job of debunking wasn't in actuality so great/convincing.

Could you quote that part of the thread? I must have missed it.

reply

It was THREE posts up from YOUR OWN post. Granted that's a LONG way away, so it's understandable how you could have missed it too.

reply

It was THREE posts up from YOUR OWN post. Granted that's a LONG way away, so it's understandable how you could have missed it too.
So.. I'm counting back three here. Apparently you consider this post:

The only problem with Ancient Aliens Debunked is 3/4ths of the way through the guy goes off on a tangent about Bible accuracy and states how unquestionable it is, and ruins the whole documentary by doing EXACTLY what he accuses AA of doing.

Worst case of pot calling the kettle black ever in the history of mankind
to have "established that his great job of debunking wasn't in actuality so great/convincing"? You'll have to forgive me for missing it because it doesn't, in any way, negate the facts the creator presents which obviously demonstrate that these Ancient Aliens charlatans have no idea what they're talking about.

reply

You'll have to forgive me then too if you think at this point I'm actually going to give you the benefit of the doubt that you're approaching this subject objectively given our past exchanges on this message board.

While your memory is apparently that bad...mine isnt.

reply

Objectively speaking, do the ancient alien theorists featured on this show frequently present as fact claims that are untrue?

reply

Objectively speaking, why are you trying to change the subject from the fact that Ancient Aliens Debunked was made/produced by a person (Chris White) with a subjective personal motivation (his own religious beliefs) for trying to debunk AA theory?

reply

1) It's strange that you won't answer such a simple question.

2) Facts are facts, regardless of the motivations of the people who present them. The AA theorists make their living off duping people into believing them, so let's not leave them out of this whole "objectivity" discussion. Why are their (unsourced) facts good and Chris White's (properly cited) facts bad?

reply

by troodon311 »
1) It's strange that you won't answer such a simple question.

2) Facts are facts, regardless of the motivations of the people who present them. The AA theorists make their living off duping people into believing them, so let's not leave them out of this whole "objectivity" discussion. Why are their (unsourced) facts good and Chris White's (properly cited) facts bad?

As I said, we've had this discussion here before.

Strange that you still seem to be trying to claim objectivity by claiming that your opinions about AA are facts.

reply

As I said, we've had this discussion here before.

Strange that you still seem to be trying to claim objectivity by claiming that your opinions about AA are facts.
So we'll make that two questions, then, that you refuse to answer.

reply

As I said, we've had this discussion here before.

by troodon311 >>So we'll make that two questions, then, that you refuse to answer.

Pot, meet kettle.

But as I said, we've had this discussion here before.

NOT so strange that you would try to start it al over again...being the troll that you are after all.

reply

Pot, meet kettle.
I guess you don't understand what this phrase means.

The pot calls the kettle black, even though the pot itself is black, making the pot a hypocrite, or at least oblivious to the fact that it's also black.

I'm saying you won't answer questions that undermine your criticisms of Chris White's film. You've only asked me one question during this discourse, which I answered, so I'm not acting in any way hypocritically.

being the troll that you are after all.
Apparently you just don't know what a 'troll' is either. Not every human being who articulates disagreement with you, and tries to show you deficiencies in your thinking, is a troll.

http://tinyurl.com/hsn72ly

reply

As I said, we've had this discussion before, where you deny you're a troll even though all you ever do while you're here is talk trash about the show the message board you're doing it on is for.

So, troll.

Your other points of contention are based on your own obvious personal opinion, and since you've ALREADY tried to pass off your opinions as facts with your "answers"...while simultaneously implying my responses should be dismissed since I don't agree with your opinions.

pot/kettle

But then I've explained that to you in the past too...and yet here you are again doing the same thing...proving it's you who still doesn't understand that your opinions aren't as conclusive as you like to think they are.

So, done.

reply