MovieChat Forums > American Pickers (2010) Discussion > A far better show is the UK Antiques Roa...

A far better show is the UK Antiques Road Trip.


You've got two dealers who have $200 pounds each. During a 4 episode stretch they PICK antique shops and barter hard to get bargains. Each episode they take the stuff to auction. These auctions usually have internet bidders too.

Why is this so superior to American Pickers? Because these dealers also think they're going to make money off every purchase, BUT YOU GET TO SEE WHETHER THEY DID OR NOT!

Mike Wolfe has this show set up to look like they hardly, if ever, make mistakes. I've seen them overpay a bunch of times, but we're always left with just what THEY THINK they'll get. Especially Frank who doesn't seem like he wants to part much with his $20,000 per episode pay. He goes into houses full of toys and focus's on the broken toys because he knows he'll be able to buy those for $10, instead of the great stuff you see all over the room.

The dealers on Antique Road Trip are doing this for charity. All the profits go to children's charities. So they do fight hard for bargains, and it's a competition. But they also make big mistakes!

I've watched these two American Picker clowns go into Gilleys and overpay for everything! and you could literally look up all the things they bought in that episode and see they are dead items on Ebay. It's because Mickey somehow managed to empty the bar before the fire! Almost like it was set on purpose?? and people know that there's more Gilleys memorabilia around than there ever was interest.

And that's just an observation from one episode. Frank and Mike lately have been buying part missing toys, bikes and motorcycles and claiming they'll make huge profits. All that kind of stuff lies around for YEARS until you connect WITH A GUY WHO NEEDS IT and is willing to pay your ransom.

It's so easy for these guys to do that, and it's becoming more and more frequent on their picks. Every local (10 mile X 10 mile area) has 50 guys storing old parts toys and bikes that they thought they'd rebuild one day, but haven't gotten around to in 40+ years and the main reason is...all the other guys with those parts act like they're worth their weight in gold and you can't even begin to restore something without possibly shelling out twice it's mint value. So it's literally a DEAD MARKET! Go to a big swap meet where guys bring out tables full of rare parts. Set up a camera and film two or three of these booths where everything is rare, and high priced. You know what you'll get 48 hours of on film? A ton of people looking, nobody buying. Because they've priced the hobby out of interest to most people. You put that stuff through an auction, the guy would be lucky to recover .33 on a dollar. They killed the hobby from greed. Mike Wolfe acts like there are slews of people running around looking to restore everything. It's just not true anymore. They can buy the cars and bikes in great condition now for 1/2 what they used to bring, why would they pay you for something they have to hunt high and low for affordable parts to? Simple answer..they don't anymore.

I'll tell you why they promote it so much. Because he's most likely sitting on a large stash himself, and would like to shock resuscitate the hobby.

To get a better idea of THE REAL MARKET watch Antiques Road Trip.

I'll explain the fluctuation. As generations pass people want the stuff THEY grew up with. There's less and less people wanting to shell out gazillions for 1900-1960's bikes daily. Because they die, and there's more of them available, and less buyers who want them. The hot stuff is 70's to 80's cars, bikes, toys. Because the collectors want them in mass! The old collectors always don't get this. That all their collecting buddies are dropping dead, and it's now onto the next generation.

This is why you recently had an episode where Mike could have bought original monster models for $3 each and only took a few, because he is not growing as a buyer/collector and is instead focused on what used to sell 25 years ago. I'm sure anybody who knows the current toy market went "Waaa waa what?" all of those were a steal at $3

Another thing about Antiques Road Trip is these are seasoned dealers who aren't one trick ponies, but are experts in a huge variety of things. They aren't limited to Bikes, toys, and advertising. They know 1000 other markets besides those 3, or four.

reply

American Pickers have ruined the market for many things. There are a lot of things i can get local for dirt cheap, Pickers want huge money. One thing i hate is they always say I will take a chance at that for 500, Are they scared to use their phones, I am not stupid, I will go shopping, Walmart, thrift stores, pawn shops, garage sales, and I will research the price of what i can buy it for shipped to my house, Most times people think things for worth more than gold. I do not take kindly to people ripping me off.

reply

I would say American Pickers made everybody think their bicycle was worth a fortune. And they act like they're literally falling over these everywhere. And people who thought they were going to corner the local Bicyle market suddenly found themselves with a bunch of bikes they can't get rid of for 25% what they overpayed.

Other than the big four, their knowledge is limited. And it's just not like they portray in their little drama. Not every out barn place is loaded with signs, bikes and toys. It's just that those are the places they accept to be on an episode. Meaning thewy're refusing to go to 50 places for every one they do choose.

Want to see? Contact em and tell them you have several acres of out buildings. They'll ask you a hundred questions about what you have, what you'd be willing to sell. They won't even be interested unless you say you have bikes, old motorcycles, signs, and toys. Then if they chose you, they'd act like Dani FOUND YOU from scouring the internet!

This show is now her side job. Her real job is making appearances! She's at every fair, auto show, swap meet. When does she have time to do all this? Answer, she never did! She never manned the phones or scoured the internet. Look at what they did with the girl running the other shop, they turned her into an antique expert in a few months, too.

Since season 1 the show became a mad collector showcase, where they (mad collectors) pretend to want to sell everything, and really only called in the show to show off their collection.

reply