MovieChat Forums > To the Wonder (2013) Discussion > Marina: Mentally Ill or just French?

Marina: Mentally Ill or just French?


So, is she Bipolar (swinging between Manic and Depressed) or "Just French"?

reply

I think she's a little bi-polar. Europeans tends to be somewhat more emotional, but she seems to be all over the place and it's not really explained as to why she's so needy and emotionally all over the place. I get she's been left (who hasn't) and Ben Affleck's character seems to be almost incapable of being the emotional rock she (and then Rachel McAdams character) need ultimately. Are they both just broken birds? Or because they're broken, they chase him away and then she becomes unscrewed and even more emotionally unstable?

reply

Europeans tends to be somewhat more emotional


LOL. Funniest thing i have read all day.

reply

LOL. Funniest thing i have read all day.


me too

reply

Sings a Russian lullaby so I think she is a Russian dancer or model in the movie, and no one doubts Russians are crazy

reply

She's actually Ukranian, which is a big difference and you'd know this with a bit of history knowledge and if you've met both Russian and Ukranian people.

-

-You won't forget me now?

-No. I've got nobody else to remember.

reply

...and your comment is somehow better?

reply

Not sure if this is a troll question, but I'll answer it seriously. Being deeply in love with someone can drive you to do crazy and irrational things. When you're in this state of mind you may not realize this. To the Wonder allows the viewer to observe how these emotions affected Marina, and what's cool is how in the context of this film Malick lets her character basically let loose and act out on her emotions where most of us manage to suppress them. She's a manifestation of the ups and downs so many people go through, things that Malick himself has probably gone through, and he uses her character as his vessel to portray the tumultuous feelings that come with being head over heels in love with someone.

reply

Yeah, when I'm in love, I endlessly go on picnics, to frolic and dance and twirl the day away. I twirl to my heart's content, since everyone knows that incessant twirling signifies happiness and spiritual closeness to the 'love that loves us'. Indeed, who doesn't love a good twirl when they're happy? Marina certainly does. She twirls it up with the best I've ever seen. Twirl among the sunflowers, twirl in the park, twirl in the supermarket, on the street, in the backyard, in the kitchen. Twirl!

An utterly dreadful, unintentionally comical film that comes across as a bad parody of Malick's past works. Even his normally elegant ain't-nature-magical visual style has become a bit of a cliché. I honestly felt sad and embarrassed for him. He was a good director once upon a time.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]