Doll Girl was the scariest of them all*Spoilers*
As I said in the title..Spoiler warning so read ahead at your own risk.
Neither the Old Woman or Fire Face really scared me once you take a good look at them..They're both quite laughable,especially Fire Face. For me however..The one thing that TRULY creeped me out in this film was when Josh went into the house in the Further and encountered Doll Girl's family. The way she creepily smiled after shooting her family and then when they all appeared in front of Josh and smiled was creepy as hell.