MovieChat Forums > Maleficent (2014) Discussion > Aurora (Elle Fanning) vs. Cinderella (Li...

Aurora (Elle Fanning) vs. Cinderella (Lily James)


Who do you like more as a character/heroine?

reply

[deleted]

Lily James as Cinderella. Elle Fanning didn't really fit the bill.

reply

Elle Fanning was terribly miscast and written.

reply

Cinderella was the much more realised character. Wasn't much to Aurora, she was a supporting character though.

reply

Elle/Aurora shes a lot prettier, not really a fan of lily james' generic face.

reply

Aurora was barely even in Maleficnt, so by default Lily James, but even Cinderella has some questionable qualities about her character.

reply

Its not really fair to compare these two as of course Cinderella had more depth she was the main character whereas in this one Maleficent was the main focus and Aurora was supporting. In this story it may be called Sleeping Beauty but she has always played very little part in the actual story. As for the actresses Lily James had more of a part to play than Elle Fanning did so again could show more range. I think i still prefer Elle Fanning as she played her supporting act very well and wasn't too overshadowed whereas there are parts in Cinderella where even though she is the main character she was overshadowed a little. But in general i like both just fine.

live and let live

reply

I wasn't a huge fan of either. Elle Fanning didn't get much in the way of character development. As in the original, she's more of a plot device than the main character.

Lily James has more screen time but even her character isn't terribly well developed.

I'm hoping Belle will be a better character.

Lizzie

To love another person is to see the face of God! - Les Miserables

reply