MovieChat Forums > Pretty Little Liars (2010) Discussion > Better group of friends: Keating 5 or Th...

Better group of friends: Keating 5 or The Liars


Which group of friends do you prefer?

The Keating Five from HTGAWM
or
The Liars from PLL?

Also both of their leaders are Annalise Keating and Alison DiLaurentis

reply

depends what you mean by better.

the PLLs are better. despite their constant betrayals they're able to get along though thats indicative of bad writing.

the thing about the keating 5 is that they're not friends... its like Asher said to Michaela, shes his family. they all are. they are people who are forced together by circumstance, they all just happen to be related in this weird way and as a result they aren't exactly friends. they can do horrible *beep* to each other than be 'cool' about it because thats how family is. their dynamic is not what i want it to be, but its extremely well written.

whereas the girls are / were friends, and when they're cool with *beep* after the facti ts more becuase the writers dont let the characters remember the terrible things they all did the night before.


*when life gives you lemons*
Sara: are you a sour lemon?

reply

Who do you think is a bigger sociopath? Annalise or Alison?

reply

its hard to say either is a sociopath at this point. alison was the bigger sociopath early on.

annalise was never a sociopath as far as we knew, she could be cold and stand by her job but she clearly is an extremely emotional woman. she's just a strong one to boot.


*when life gives you lemons*
Sara: are you a sour lemon?

reply

Who's more loyal Annalise or Alison?

reply

Annalise by far i would say. shes come back for those kids time and time again after they murdered her husband. she of course has some self serving in there, even in protecting wes she's attempting to force redemption.

but alison has dropped the girls multiple times.


*when life gives you lemons*
Sara: are you a sour lemon?

reply

Do you think Alison would have saved the girls out of the Dollhouse if she didn't know that was her sibiling?

reply

Wanna know what's funny both Alison and Annalise have been framed for a murder they didn't commit

reply

The Liars...honestly it shouldn't even be a comparison because the Keating 5 were thrust together for school and then eventually tragedy.

Even though the Liars fight and argue, when push comes to shove they've remained loyal and have each others backs.

Connor is a b'tch to the highest degree of bitchiness and I'm sure he's going to be the one to dime out the entire squad. Wes was a cinnamon roll who had a hard life and didn't deserve much of what he got. Pull hard enough on a piece of thread and the Keating 5 will come tumbling apart.



Peace, Love, and Soul 

reply

Who do u think is more loyal Annalise or Alison?

reply