MovieChat Forums > One Day (2011) Discussion > Can anyone somewhat relate to Dexter and...

Can anyone somewhat relate to Dexter and Emma's relationship?


I'd say I had something similar, but it didn't go on for decades like with Dexter and Emma.

www.myspace.com/myheavenlyangel7

reply

i kind of relate ...

she is my best friend now, we know each other since we're 11 (we're both 26 now) dated for months after college, and i moved overseas, i've been visiting her annually [actually traveling long distances] , after two bad break-ups i though we would end up together someday, but now she is pregnant with a dude she dated for a month, and they are together =/

i'm not sure if it really relates, but ending up with a best friend sounds too good? what do you think?

-------
i have no signature :(

reply

Sometimes ending up with your best friend is good and possible because you know about each other from the very beginning with no secrets. I dated someone on and off for years. It wasn't until year 5 that he realized he loved me and didn't want other girls. He was like Dexter: into himself and loved the ladies. I was more like Emma: bookworm and late bloomer.

www.myspace.com/myheavenlyangel7

reply

Sort of, except that guy in my life was never available as anything more than a friend. It also hasn't gone on for decades...more like a couple of yrs.

reply

I totally can in many varied ways.

This film really hit me like a ton of bricks. Chronologically, it was almost exactly the length of our relationship i.e. we graduated college in 1988, ups and downs over the years, she later married though we remained close. She also died in 2009 of breast cancer. She actually looked something like Emma/Anne as well. Other things as well..."St Swithin's Day" was sort of "our" song, she loved the book/film "The Unbearable Lightness of Being" etc etc...not to be overly maudlin/dramatic but in many ways that was "our" relationship depicted in the book (which I haven't read yet) and/or film.

reply

Wow. Strange synchronicity for you. Your post brings tears to my eyes. How unrequited it sounds, but I believe you both will meet again in another life.

"Unbearable Lightness of Being" is an amazing book and great movie. You should see it, but maybe alone to leave space for the catharsis it may cause. Then see "The Fountain" and you will feel the loss less and the possibilities more.

Mine is still an ongoing saga, and I see alot of similarities with Dex and Emma, especially with personalities. We met in 1979 when we were both 17 and it was love at first sight, but proximity, poor timing and some bad decisions on each end has kept us apart. We've gone through some heartbreaking attempts to be together, but maybe it's just the friendship that is meant to happen for us in this life. I've only lately started to see some of the lessons of it all. There's reasons for everything and he, like Dex, also has a daughter - sometimes people are meant to be, and then, like Emma, not to be.

reply

I just wish we could be together but for some reason she doesnt.....Its very complicated to explain here I guess.


it's probably because you're boring

reply

[deleted]

Absolutely - when I read this book I felt like someone understood what I was going through.
We met in 2007 when we were 16 and there was a connection. I was insecure and nervous so I didn't let him get close to me in case I disappointed him or something. So we stayed friends...kind of.
It's been a very stormy friendship because I have strong feelings for him and he either had a gf or was seeing other people when he knows how I feel. We argued all the time over what happened in the past and we've both hurt each other a lot.
Over the yrs he's also sent me all sorts of weird messages and to this day I have no idea how he feels.
A couple of weeks ago he ended things with his gf and he came to my place and we kissed and stuff.
I can't let him go even though I want to. It's like I'm convinced it'll work out.
When I read the book at the start of 2011 I felt like someone got what I felt like.
I know I'm only young and maybe being a tad over-dramatic haha.
...I seriously feel like reading the book again just to clear my head.

'Love is becoming a blank that lovers must fill in themselves'

reply

A lot of times, I think more females are accepting of male friends like this. We don't really want to get mixed up with a so-called player. Yet, there are some men in the same boat because, after all ..they are the good guys. Maybe too good.

There is that feeling we have of saving someone, yet..not always up to the aftermath.

Modern romance is somewhat more self-absorption than anything these days. Perhaps, that counts for modern times and all the conveniences we have. And those Irish tales can only be told for so long. Drifter meets girl at the fair. Have one nighter. She has his kid and he never sees her again. Yet one of my favorite versions would be from the book (not the movie) Felicia's Journey.

What was interesting about the film was how the male was successful so soon and didn't know how to handle it while she struggled with jobs she didn't necessary like. Yet, I think this made her character all the more stronger.

reply

[deleted]

Yes I can.

I met a friend (let's call her Anne) years ago who I would see once a year, more or less on that same day, for the next couple years at our mutual friend's birthday party. I would wait all year just so I could see her. I think it was the second year after I met her that she came to the party with a boyfriend. A boyfriend that she is still with to this day.

Fast-forward a few years, and one night I finally got to know Anne. We got along famously, like we had known each other for years. From that a great, effortless, natural friendship grew between she and I.

Some time later, a group of us went out to dinner. Anne and I were very close the entire night, a lot of physical contact, and the spark that existed between us grew and grew. Sometime that night, I realized I was crazy about this girl. There was a picture taken of the two of us, and in it I have never looked so happy. I have my arm around the girl of my dreams.

Time went by, and I saw her now and again. I was involved with other girls, but the spark was always there for Anne, if only deep down. Anne and I began to spend time alone together. Nothing happened beyond talking and some closeness on the couch, but there was the aura of romance in the air.

One night Anne came over again and began to open up to me, saying that her parents don't like her boyfriend because [basically] he's a bum who can't hold a job and could never support Anne as a wife. The way Anne told me this, it was like she begrudgingly accepted that there was no future with him. She also told me that she can talk to me in a way that she can't with anyone else, not even her boyfriend.
It was around this time that Anne began to call me her husband, and talk about our future. When I would further the conversation, she would withdraw.

I have always felt that Anne has had feelings for me, and I think she knows that I have always had feelings for her. It was just like in One Day, Emma and Dexter always want to be with each other but for a while no one really explicitly says it.
There's something between us that is so natural, and like I said earlier, effortless. I hope that one day something can happen between us, but I can't hold my breath. She has always said she is going to marry her boyfriend, and I'm just waiting for that day, if it ever comes (for reasons stated above.) With that in the back of my mind, I have tried to distance myself from her so I don't get too deep into something that will never go anywhere, but one way or another she and I end up together again, and the spark re-ignites.
On top of all that, friends who have no idea I have feelings for Anne have told me that she and I should be together, or asked why we're not. Hell, I'm pretty sure my mother even wants me to be with her!

We'll see what the future holds. Maybe by year eighteen we'll be together.


_________
-'What do you look for in another human being?'
-'Stone Cold Steve Austin...'

reply

Yes. And I actually found the film a sobering reflection.

My story is still writing itself, and with that said, I think I have a train to catch.

reply

[deleted]

Listen to yourself man, just read what you just wrote.. STOP being a *beep* and go get the girl, let go of your fears, there is nothing worse than regretting something that could have been great because you pushed it away.
I honestly wish you the best

reply