Margaret Haddican-McEnroe "Hometown Hero" episode
Margaret Haddican-McEnroe disappeared from Warren Township, NJ and is still missing. That was the "Hometown Hero" episode. Haddican-McEnroe had served in the Army and was a firefighter. Her husband waited two days to report her as missing.
There was one scene that surprised me. Someone from local law enforcement said something like because he worked for an affluent community with a low crime rate so he was able to spend more time on the case. Most small town cops I have met try very hard to act like real cops and not meter maids who direct traffic to shopping malls.