Detailed review on quiet earth


source http://www.quietearth.us/articles/2010/12/06/Whistler-FF-2010-Review-of-Panos-Cosmatos-BEYOND-THE-BLACK-RAINBOW

In 1966, Dr. Arboria conducted an experiment. The goal was to create a new version of the human being, one with a conscious connection to spirituality. His test subject, Barry Nyle, emerged from the test, an odd, drug induced trip, a changed man but not necessarily in the way Dr. Arboria intended. The mad Barry inpregnates a woman and Elena, the child of the union is born with telepathic abilities. Locked in the belly of the Arboria Institute from birth, Elena suffers through regular sessions with her therapist, the re-invented but still crazy Dr. Nyle, all the while, looking for a way to escape. Keeping her in check is a mysterious machine that spawns into action each time Elena uses her powers. The machine debilitates and sedates her for a short period of time but its not really clear who or what controls it.

When Nyle pays a visit to the nearly dead, drug addicted Dr. Arboria, things take a turn for the worse. Nyle completely abandons his facade of good doctor for that of crazed and creepy stalker in search of Elena who has made her escape while Nyle is busy with Dr. Arboria.

I can't, with just one viewing, truly make sense of everything that director Panos Cosmatos presents in Beyond the Black Rainbow but the truth can't be denied: his feature film debut is one of the most exciting the sci-fi genre has seen in years. Borrowing heavily from the look and feel of 70s and 80s sci-fi and paying homage to everything from Cronenberg's The Brood to George Lucas' THX 1138, Cosmatos presents a trippy, awe inspiring vision that made my head spin. While some try to “re-invision” 80s classics, Cosmatos has chosen instead to make a film that feels authentic to the era, complete with a hypnotic synth score, timeless set design, heavily stylized visuals and a handful of the creepiest images caught on film this year, some of which seem lifted from a drug induced dream.

Cosmatos' vision is brought to life by Michael Rogers in the role of Nyle and new comer Eva Allan as Elena. Rogers gives himself fully to the role and breathes creepy life into Dr. Nyle while later transforming himself into a nearly unrecognizable deranged hunter. Allan has the difficult task of developing a character we care for while never uttering a single line of dialogue (outside of a garbled sentence she mentally forces onto Dr. Nyle). Allan emotes brilliantly – it's only a matter of time before we see what she's capable of with a speaking role.

It would be easy to brush away Cosmatos' film as a tribute to a time past and an all looks no substance sci-fi thriller but I love that Cosmatos challenges the audience by throwing out ideas, often with little explanation, while also playing with different stylistic approaches within the film. Beyond the Black Rainbow isn't all an Argento inspired palette of classic sci-fi. In a flashback sequence, Cosmatos opts for a blown out black and white approach which gives the sequence a twisted horror film feel almost as if it's too brutal to show and only appropriate to see in shadows. It's a gutsy move and one that works to great effect.

Beyond the Black Rainbow is a melting pot of thoughts and visuals, a mix of sci-fi and horror; a film that is guaranteed to be a cult classic, a hit with the midnight crowds and a must see for anyone interested in a film experience. With his debut, Cosmatos shows great promise as a visionary director, one who is ripe to breathe some new life into the sci-fi genre.

reply

The movie works best if you've only seen the trailer. How about a goddamned spoiler alert in the title??

reply

*beep* you.

reply

*beep* you. There we go.

reply

The mad Barry inpregnates a woman and Elena, the child of the union is born with telepathic abilities

Interesting... so maybe I was right that Dr. Nyle was her father. My friends and I disagreed about this, and I can certainly see why they thought otherwise. The psychic link between Arboria and the girl seemed to suggest they were related somehow.

TV: http://ihatemydvr.blogspot.com
LOST:http://eyemsick.blogspot.com

reply

I just stopped reading that article because I thought the "Nyle as dad" claim was blatantly wrong. I thought it was very clear that Arboria was her dad but maybe it's not the case...

HAIL TO THE CHIMP! http://i35.tinypic.com/1zoxa4m.gif

reply

@Necrometer: I got the vibe Nyle raped the woman after his transformation. It would make sense that Elena inherited her powers from him. I inferred he was obsessed with reproducing with his daughter to create an even more powerful being.

TV: http://ihatemydvr.blogspot.com
LOST:http://eyemsick.blogspot.com

reply

I thought he immediately killed her. I think the woman was only shown from the shoulders up to hide her pregnancy. It was pretty clear that her death coincided with the birth of the child, since Arboria made some comment about her death not being in vain. I think she obtained similar powers to Nyle's by being put through the same process he was: being dunked in that pool. His obsession with reproducing with her would still apply (and make more sense since it wouldn't be incest) if she gained the powers the same way that he did.

HAIL TO THE CHIMP! http://i35.tinypic.com/1zoxa4m.gif

reply

@Necrometer: I thought he was saying she died during childbirth.

Why would Aboria allow Nyle to kill her? A sexual union would be tolerable because it was necessary to advance human evolution. But murder? Wouldn't you expect him to fear -- or at least resent -- Nyle in that case?

TV: http://ihatemydvr.blogspot.com
LOST:http://eyemsick.blogspot.com

reply

I don't think he allowed it - it was shown very quickly that he strikes her and blood shot out. At least that's what I remember seeing. Arboria didn't anticipate any negative consequences from the transformation so it was a surprise to him. I think Arboria's calm reaction to the death was just another example of his limitless optimism.

HAIL TO THE CHIMP! http://i35.tinypic.com/1zoxa4m.gif

reply

Not death, murder. Isn't the latter precisely the sort of impulse the Institute was meant to overcome?* Either way, there's a big difference.

Also, this speculation requires that a dead woman give birth. It's ambiguous but an assault followed by death during childbirth makes more sense to me.

*In fairness, though, so is rape.

TV: http://ihatemydvr.blogspot.com
LOST:http://eyemsick.blogspot.com

reply

> "Not death, murder. Isn't the latter precisely the sort of impulse the Institute was meant to overcome? Either way, there's a big difference."
I think we have plenty of reason to believe that the institute's research sometimes has unintended consequences!

> "Also, this speculation requires that a dead woman give birth. An assault followed by death during childbirth makes much more sense to me."
My interpretation is that Nyle murdered her right after his emergence, and the child was immediately delivered to save its life.

HAIL TO THE CHIMP! http://i35.tinypic.com/1zoxa4m.gif

reply

Watched that bit again online. Your interpretation seems 100% correct. Cheers!

TV: http://ihatemydvr.blogspot.com
LOST:http://eyemsick.blogspot.com

reply

OK, cool. Thanks - now I am not second-guessing myself!

HAIL TO THE CHIMP! http://i35.tinypic.com/1zoxa4m.gif

reply

[deleted]

If you remember when Dr. Nyle is have a session with Elena she telepathically communicates with him the words.....I want to see my father.....right before that scene she is given a picture of her mother and as she is looking at it she begins to sense a heartbeat, when she walks up to the wall and puts her face against the wall she remotely searches the institute and you see a shot of a white wall and a door, right before the pyramid id turned on and impedes Elena's search....that is the same room that Dr. Nyle walks in to to see Dr. Aboria....

reply

It's never stated that Dr. Nyle is Elena's dad, he only killed her mom. It's never stated who her father is, but it would seem more likely that Dr. Arboria is the father.

reply

@radiosity: did he kill her or rape her? If it's clear he killed her, then I agree he's probably not Elena's father.

EDiT: Never mind, you're right, he killed her.

TV: http://ihatemydvr.blogspot.com
LOST:http://eyemsick.blogspot.com

reply

Indeed, in the credits she's listed with a last name of Arboria.

reply