MovieChat Forums > Exodus: Gods and Kings (2014) Discussion > Don't people realize most of the Exodus ...

Don't people realize most of the Exodus book is simply not true?


Look it up anywhere you want, even the Catholic Bibles introduction to Exodus clearly spell out that there's no historical basis to believe the historicity of the book.

No evidence of Hebrew presence in Egypt, nor of mass/sudden exit of population (nor the economic cataclysm such a loss of slave labour would have caused), nor the loss of the Egyptian army (would have left Egypt vulnerable to be conquered and depleted of male population).

Plus a couple inconvenient facts:
- The Moses/arc/Sinai story only became mainstream AFTER the Babylonian captivity. In the northern kingdom of Israel, Moses and the Egypt captivity were nonexistent. That story only existed on the southern kingdom of Judah.
- Historical records show that the god of Abraham was indeed El, and only became Yahweh after the Babylonian Exile (Yahweh even had a wife, Ashera, and the Jerusalem temple and many households had her statues).
- The closest people that could possibly be the Hebrews in Egypt were the Hyksos, whom were conquerors, rulers and had to be kicked out. Not exactly the noble image Jews have of themselves.

So long story short:
- Hebrews were for the most part Natives to Canaan, were Canaanite themselves (El was a Canaanite god)
- A few of them may have descended on to Egypt
- Moses, if he even existed, was most likely a Madia priest whom introduced the cult of Yahweh into the people whom settled in the kingdom of Judah.
- Israel was quite polytheist.
- the 10 plagues are clearly based off natural disasters that occurred here and there over time (why nobody can place them all within any time period to match the alleged exodus).
- Whatever massacres/genocides/exterminations the Hebrews are said to have done were the rule of the land, and most likely embellishments (Jericho for example has been shown not to have been the huge fortification described in the OT).

And that's that. I don't know nor care about whether Jews actually believe tit to be literally factual (most seem to have no problem realizing the Flintstones are not a documentary unlike many evangelical Protestants), Christians sure don't need to take it literally either.

reply

Plus, John Turturo is not an Egyptian, he's in fact Italian who migrated to America and invented baseball!

reply

lol

reply

If you look at the top of each gospel, you'll see something like, "The gospel according to...", which the literal interpretation means that the story was passed down, and re-told over and over again from and to different people, and also translated from one language to another. Ever heard of the Telephone Game?

_
Every person that served can be called a veteran, but not every veteran can be called a Marine.

reply

> Look it up anywhere you want, even the Catholic Bibles introduction to Exodus clearly spell out that there's no historical basis to believe the historicity of the book.

I think most people accept that almost everything in the Bible is an embellishment of various ordinary events. The Great Flood was likely just a yearly flood, parting the Red Sea was just low tide, and so on.

In any case, this movie told an epic adventure and backed it up with stunning visuals and special effects. I gave it high marks for that. Of course, the story itself is no more true than your typical super hero movie. I enjoyed it for being an engaging and exciting adventure.

I particularly enjoyed the attempts to be a reasonable portrayal of civilization 3,000 years ago. Someone did a lot of research and thinking about what life was like back then.

--
What Would Jesus Do For A Klondike Bar (WWJDFAKB)?

reply