MovieChat Forums > The Walking Dead (2010) Discussion > The Maggie Negan confrontation .... ( p...

The Maggie Negan confrontation .... ( possible spoiler )


This scene was such a disappointment, if only because it made no sense.

In that terribly stupid scene the clever trickster Negan knew that if he did stand up and attack and even kill Maggie, Michonne would definitely kill him, so his only recourse was to pretend to be pitiful and appeal to Maggie's mercy .... and the normally determined and steeled Maggie stupidly fell for it.

This is one reason why you never to right into a fight after a long trip and exertion ... you will have and energy deficit and not be thinking straight. Negan played her, getting her all riled up with his provocations - which it made no sense that Maggie could just come down from in mere seconds to sparing his life?

Negan decided the only gambit he could play to stay alive was to pretend he was pitiful and broken. Maggie blew it by losing her grit and normally steely determination ... in fact she should have found Lucille, or constructed a fake Lucille and bashed Negan's disgusting brains out or just shot him in his cell. She was totally right, and now Negan can sit in prison and plot his return.

Why Maggie would even give him the chance to attack her? There is still the fact that most men are bigger and stronger than most women and Negan would very well have turned the tables on Maggie and killed her. This was a terrible scene.

This proves the point again that on most critical scenes the Walking Dead can confidently be counted on to blow it and do the most stupid thing.

reply

I don't think she pitied him. I think she figured out that he suffered more languishing in a cell. And that satisfied her to some degree knowing he continued to suffer...
Killing him would be a mercy.
Sometimes living does seem the most cruel punishment.
It would to me.





reply

^Thjs

reply

It's just very short sighted. I mean, it's not like he's in real prison with armed guards etc. He's in apocalypse jail that doesn't seem to be guarded. It wouldn't be out of the question for a group of sympathizers to break him out/force his return. It's inevitable.

His location is known, he still has acolytes/a following of some degree. They could easily use the safety of the population of Alexandria as leverage to let him out if they found their balls.

That's why whatever the US government says about the mission to get OBL, it was always just kill, never capture or kill. Having him in custody would turn the dial on the nutjobs to 11 demanding his release with threats of terror attacks.

reply

Thing is I doubt anyone like Negan, they join the saviours mostly out of fear and to survive. He prob have no one that can be truly called his friends so they arent going risk their lives to rescue him besides they arent allow to have any firearms after the war

reply

Well I imagine the group that Carol burnt to a crisp were fairly loyal to him. As for firearms, there's what, around 400M of them in the US. If theirs were confiscated, I can't imagine it would be a massive effort to scrounge up some more.

reply

Keep him alive in that world and somehow, someway he will get free and hurt other people. It is a question of protection and justice. If I was Glenn or Abraham, I would demand it, or anyone else too. Negan is am evil mad dog and as long as he lives people are in danger, in a world where there is enough danger to everyone, every day.

reply

Yes, all true IMO. But also, per the comics, [spoiler] this is what happens, albeit, with Negan having been on the move.[/spoiler]

reply