MovieChat Forums > The Walking Dead (2010) Discussion > The Walking Dead Say Yes To The Deer

The Walking Dead Say Yes To The Deer


There was a moment on "Say Yes," tonight's installment of THE WALKING DEAD, wherein Rick and Michonne are discussing the future and imagining the downfall of Negan's order. Someone, Michonne suggests, is going to have to be in charge of reordering the world of the survivor communities."It should be you," she tells Rick. "You can do it. You'd be good at it." Rick, of course, has never shown himself to be "good at" much of anything in TWD's long run. One of show's tropes is that the writers, perpetually lost in the fever of Idiot Plot Syndrome, always show Rick to be entirely incompetent then, to justify his continuing position as leader, try to do an end-run around their own bad plotting by having the other characters constantly talking about what a great leader he is. Don't believe your lying eyes! Immediately after Michonne suggests he's cut out to be Maximal Leader, the writers give us another look at Rick's typical leadership skills. He and Michonne, out scavenging for guns and supplies, have happened upon what appears to be an old county fair that, when the world was falling apart, was apparently used by the military as some sort of base of operations. Everyone there, soldiers and civilians alike, are long dead but the many soldier-zombies are still toting their weaponry. Jackpot! But there are probably over a hundred zombies inside the fairground. Does Rick high-five Michonne and return home to collect some extra muscle to take the place? Nope. He decides he and Michonne will try to take on this army of the dead all by themselves.

Clearly, the guy who should be running the world.[1]

The discovery of the fairground, which also came with tons of still-boxed-and-shrink-wrapped MREs, was another magic-trick by the writers who, having wasted over half this season on filler material, are now jamming in these huge, paradigm-altering discoveries one after another. When last we saw Rick, he'd cut a deal with the Garbage People (who were another magic trick); if Rick could arm them, they'd fight with him. Presto! The next time we see Rick, he's finding exactly what he needed, and no one from any of the communities, all of whom have been scavenging throughout this area for something approaching two years, have ever come across it! Other than being just what they needed, the site doesn't make a lot of sense either. There are shell-casings scattered around that suggest there was some sort of ferocious fight yet the perimeter fences appear to be entirely unbreached and most of the soldier-zombies are walking around with their weapons conveniently slung and holstered, as if they somehow died without having used them at all. Bored to death while on guard duty? One of the mysteries of TWD...

The rest is here:
http://cinemarchaeologist.blogspot.com/2017/03/walking-dead-90.html

reply

Agreed jr, it was a totally ridiculous episode.

reply

That deer was the funniest, worse CGI crap I have seen in a long time.

reply

Ah, yep. It certainly was.

reply

Deer computer graphics was horrible. If you're not going to make it look real, at least take the time to get a real deer. AMC has time, money and resources. There was no need to make it look as fake as it did.

reply

"If you're not going to make it look real, at least take the time to get a real deer."

In Georgia, you can get nearly every kind of animal actor. I suppose it's possible there were no real deer available when they needed to shoot but it seems pretty unlikely. In Atlanta, you can get camels, zebras, even kangaroos for movies; you can't come up with a single real deer in a state that has over 1 million of them? Animals can be a real pain on a set but I can't believe a real one, which you'd only need for two scenes, wouldn't be much cheaper than creating an entirely CGI one.

reply

I hate seeing real animals used. It just makes me angry that they are easily exploited for man's entertainment. CGI is OK with me

reply

"much cheaper than creating an entirely CGI one." Unfortunately, the CGI made the scene look cheap, so it definitely wasn't a great decision.

reply

You said it all right there, jriddle73. You forgot they weren't far from seeing the Saviors also. I'm sure they were still within their hearing with all the gun shots. There are so many inconsistencies and implausible scenarios, I can read the headline now after it ends, "Greatest Hoax Pulled on TWD Viewers". If it weren't for watching fom the beginning, I'd have let this show go. I would watch it when it came on in anticipation, and now I DVR it and don't watch until 3 or 4 days following.

reply

now I DVR it and don't watch until 3 or 4 days following.

Well, for me, a day or so later.

reply