A show has to work with what is there. The kids were clearly cast to fit into their "one character trait each" roles, and pretty well at that time. But while the actors grew out if this, the show never followed, as it would have meant not being able to cash in on the same running gags we know since episode 1.
A possible variation would have been to have two sexy daughters, creating competition.
Also playing out the "beautiful genius" would have been an option, as it would have felt increasingly unfair towards the siblings, which could have been a way to really hits where it hurts and to create relevant comedy instead of the same harmless jokes over and over again.
Luke could have a new cheerleader bimbo every episode, instead they try to cram him into a role of being the inhibited teenager, which he would have fit in, if he still were that chubby little kid of the first season.
Haley on the other hand has suprised so often by not being totally dull that the "dumb beauty" trope does not fit anymore and yet the show has not managed to really replace it with something else.
And Lily is still handled as the the wise-beyond-age baby.
reply
share