MovieChat Forums > Modern Family (2009) Discussion > I kind of feel bad for Luke

I kind of feel bad for Luke


Everyone underestimates and label him as the "dumb" or "weird" kid and whatnot.

Haley and Alex treat like like crap, even worse than Haley and Alex used to treat each other. They put makeup on him and forced the girl he liked to leave.

Claire and Phil once acknowledged each of their kid's strengths (Alex the Genius and Haley the gorgeous/confident one). But for Luke, they had nothing...............pretty sad.

reply

But, Phil did say Luke was his favorite kid! ;-)

reply

Yes. So did Claire. Despite being the weakest, both the parents love him the most..

reply

When did Claire say she favored Luck the most?

"I'm doing good in the game, so I'm doing good in life!" - Charlie Kelly

reply

I do believe they actually said more than once that he's an inquisitive child - as a compliment. Something along the lines of him asking a lot of questions and trying to figure things out. Also, he has a gentle soul and is very intuitive. That's character development they've given him over the years.

As for how the kids treat each other, anyone who has one or more sibling knows that it's just what happens. I remember painting my brothers and father's toenails, putting make up on them, and tying their hair up in (stunted) pigtails. We teased each other relentlessly, but the moment that someone else tried to tease them, we'd crack it and defend them to the end. Siblings do that. And we definitely used to (still do?) love embarrassing each other in front of boyfriends/girlfriends. That's why I no longer introduce boyfriends to my family - defence mechanism.

reply

I mostly blow off Luke being a misfit of sorts because it's a pretty typical formula for family-oriented sitcoms. One kid is the brain, one is the jock and/or popular, one is the oddball (or given no real identity), and it's usually the youngest. Seriously, think of other sitcoms with three kids--it's almost always that way.

Should "Modern Family" be better? Yeah, and I feel like they do give him more than predecessors. As others have said, his father adores him (actually favors), and his sister seem to mostly treat him the status quo for a younger sibling... not just in TV Land but in real life.

reply

I had really high hope for Luke too, especially after Phil said

I have been waiting for this day ...ever since the doctor pointed to the ultrasound of your mom's womb and said, either that's a fifth limb-


I imagine him and Phil would be the type to have successful career in science. As I vaguely recall, Luke demonstrated a great mind for nonlinear optimization on a few occasions. Too bad this is not how the writers look at it and instead of doing something new they turned Luke into an archetype.

Alex on the other hand, has only ever been known to be able to remember a lot of trivia. I was quite confused when the characters kept refer to her as "genius". I am not impressed by the ability to quote things (which she spent all her time on - I mean if you spend 80% of your waking moment reading about fish for example, you'd be able to quote a lot of random facts about fish!). I am partially impressed by the ability to do arithmetic operation to the 4-5th significant digits, I think Alex demonstrated this once ? only that this skill would be useful if you are on a game show or want to perform at party for your friends, it is not even useful in adult's mathematics.
I remember some episode there was a part Alex and her friend had to solve a "difficult" problem, their laptop was broken and they couldn't reproduce their result on the board (lol). And what I saw on the board was vector dynamics (something I expect would cause trouble for the average student in junior high), and of course, numbers with unnecessarily long precision...
Is it too expensive to get some first, second year college students to advise them on these silly technical matters ? pretty sure it shouldn't be, most of them always look for short term part time jobs. Hell, you dont even need to pay cash. I know many math/physics majors would do this for Starbucks coupons  You just need to post an ad on campus, and you can ask them stuffs like "hey, does this sound smart ?", "is this what a good problem solver in your field would say ?" etc.


reply

Not that this has anything to do with this thread but I read somewhere the actor who plays Luke has a very high IQ

reply

That's true. Nolan Gould is even a member of Mensa.

_______
The sun is shining... but the ice is slippery.

reply

They've show Luke to have a high aptitude a couple of times, that I recall, once with a really nice singing voice, and a real talent for mastering magic tricks, but in both of those cases Luke just doesn't care enough about those talents to pursue anything. He is sort of a multi-talented type who prefers to not do much, haha.

reply