MovieChat Forums > Modern Family (2009) Discussion > Phil getting "locked" in a closet is so ...

Phil getting "locked" in a closet is so implausible...


There have been so many episodes showing how Phil is a good handyman, good with fixing things and building things and putting things together, etc. Yet he can't open a simple closet door for 18 hours?

reply

Good handyman? He couldn't get the water heater pilot light lit. The tree house was a dangerous disaster. The broken step was shoddily repaired and soon defective again. Bob Vila he isn't.

While true he does show moments of clarity he also is hyper-emotional, and has a tendency to panic when stressed, losing the ability for rational behavior. Him freaking out in the hotel room when Robot Phil malfunctioned when he simply could have phoned the family is another example. Besides, it motivates humor like Phil hilariously rationing out the Tick Tacs.

"I'm doing good in the game, so I'm doing good in life!" - Charlie Kelly

reply

A big example of him being a drama queen that I remember was when he crashed on Jays motorcycle and started filming like 127 hours lol.

reply

"Why didn't I wear my shaaaaaaaaaants?!" LOL

And then he got upset because there was tomato on his sub. HA! ;-)

reply

well, there have been many episodes where he is good with electronics (setting up new television systems, wiring, putting in computers/printer). So I would think having at least that technical knowledge, he would somehow be able to figure out how to get out of a closet.

reply

[deleted]

That scene where he was rationing out the tic tacs and crying was so funny and classic Phil.

reply

My problem with it is that the handle fell completely off on both sides of the door. All he had to do was pull the cylinder out.

reply

yes, that was exactly what I was referring to. It would be different if it were a different situation that got him locked in and he couldn't figure it out, but as you said - it was as simple as the handle fell off, and you would think with his other technical knowledge (and yes, I am aware that someone pointed out that electronics aren't the same as construction type skills) he would be able to figure it out.

reply

We have seen him enter houses twice through windows - the divorcee in the Bicycle episode, and Cam and Mitchell's house in the (Hawaii?) episode - he said it was a skill realtors need.

reply

He's said that a lot of problems as a realtor has to do with keys. You'd think between that and his love of magic he'd learn how to pick a lock, at least know enough how to move the latch & free himself.




(this signature was absent on picture day)

reply

Metamorphosis!

reply

Hes tech savvy not handy there's a difference.
That little scene seemed like it was an afterthought to give him something to do in the episode

reply