MovieChat Forums > You Again (2010) Discussion > Revenge is sweet. Just don't overdo it.

Revenge is sweet. Just don't overdo it.


But it really depends on what was done to the victim. It's been said that revenge is sweet, but forgiveness is sweeter. It's up to me. It's up to you. It's up to everyone.

'Forgive, but don't forget.' And always accept a heartfelt apology.

reply

Those sure are words to live by!

reply

Revenge can be sweet, but it's a case by case thing. It depends on the individual person being targeted for revenge, the misdeeds that need to be answered for, the type of revenge, and the consequences of that revenge. For example, The Bride in Kill Bill or Cady Heron in Mean Girls, they got some SWEEEEET satisfaction!!!

In the case of You Again, our heroine, Marni found her revenge (overdone or not) on former high school nemesis, Joanna to be empty and hollow. Joanna was a despicable person in her teenage years - a Queen Bee and bully who would have deserved her comeuppance...back THEN. But this is now, and Marni did not get her expected satisfaction because the target of her revenge basically no longer exists. Plus it damaged her relationship with her brother and parents.

Joanna is not the conventional movie villain/antagonist. She is a very flawed human being, but she is not a psychopath or close to being one. If she was, the audience would have been rooting for Marni to the end, and not be left so confused and conflicted. After all, another rehash of the classic good girl vs. bad girl catfight - what could be more simple or satisfying? Many people wanted to see the bad girl get punished, and were disappointed when that expectation was not trully fulfilled. Joanna outgrew the bad girl persona (the death of her parents was a factor), and came to regret the hurt she caused others. So why doesn't she just acknowledge knowing Marni in the first place, and give the heart felt apology she wanted? Well, people often deal with guilt by using the psychological defence mechanisms of denial and sublimation. Joanna tried to erase her troubled past by pretending it never happened, so she can start over again as a new person. She tried to establish a fresh new relationship with Marni, like strangers meeting for the first time. She became a nurse and got involved in charity work to help others. In contrast, Marni outgrew her meek persona, and became a strong, successful woman climbing the corporate ladder. Both women tried to distance themselves from the persons they once were.




"When I'm good, I'm GOOD. When I'm bad, I'm BETTER."

reply

[deleted]

Amen, thank Heaven and thank you! :)!

reply

Ugh. The bully character's apology couldn't possibly have been sincere, because she'd been bullying the protagonist as recently as the day before. I just can't buy her sudden change of character. I think it was just she was sorry for being found out. And was eating carbs.

reply

I didn't buy her ''apology'' either. How can she be suddenly sorry after threwing plates at Marni and later on that green slime?

She was only sorry after her Will sees her still bullying Marni (when he walked in on Joanna throwing the bowl of slime)... that fact that she was about to lose Will and couldn't hide it anymore.

Sorry but if it was me and it took forever to get that apology, I would not even assist the wedding.

reply