The show's definition of evil is problematic
This past episode really highlighted how the rules for "evil" and going to Hell in this universe are pretty dumb. For example, killibg the one guy for Cade because he would have rather the other anonymous people die instead of him. Thats a reaction that 90 percent of the human population would also do if they didn't know anyone really well that was in danger.
Then, Sybil threatens Caroline saying that she will kill students if Caroline doesn't cooperate, but the death of the students would go on Caroline's "hell scorecard"? That's horrible logic. A parallel scenario would be a psychopath saying that if the girl he stalks wont submit, he will kill ger parents, and she'd get blamed for it and it would be on her "hell" scorecard. How can this season truly be about redemption if