Some People Don't Get This Film


I've read some user reviews that liken this film to a bad episode of "Jerry Springer," and/or claim that it has no redeeming value and nothing to say. I have to strongly disagree with those folks -- I think the film is a masterpiece of documentary filmmaking, and is far more humane and profound than one might realize upon first viewing. Granted, we are invited to view the Whites as human trainwrecks, with their rampant drug use/dealing, violence, and utter disregard for societal norms. They ARE human trainwrecks. But while much of the film is devoted to their hedonism, the last third takes a very serious, heartbreaking turn, in which we witness their actions catching up with them: Sue Bob weeping over her son's prison sentence, Kirk's baby being taken away, her having to go to rehab and say goodbye to the little boy who clearly adores her. The film has a profound arc, and none of it is forced or scripted: all of this occured within the span of the year the White family was filmed. It's both tragedy and comedy, sometimes simultaneously, just like the everyday life that all of us lead.

reply

Agreed. I did not feel it glorified the White's lifestyle at all; in fact, quite the opposite. As well, it was sooo creative, entertaining, and interesting to watch, strictly from a filmmaking standpoint. The music, editing, and the shots themselves made it extremely watchable from start to finish.

DRAGON¸.•´¸.•*´¨SWAK¸.•*¨¸.•´¸.•*´¨) ¸.•*¨
(¸.•´ ¸.•*¨¸.•´¸.•*´¨(¸.•´ ¸.•´

reply

It's a film you watch over and over and catch things you missed the last time. I really hope they catch up with them again to see what everyone is doing.

reply

[deleted]

I think it's possible to "get" the film, and still not be able to stomach the people it focuses on. My distress over the Whites was what caused me to turn it off - not any lack of film-making chops. It's a tribute to the creative team that I'm thinking about watching the rest. I may not be able to keep watching these people no matter how well presented their lives.

reply

I thought that a small portion of the film glorified the, uh, legend of the White family. I can see some people viewing this and thinking these people were idiots, but still admiring elements of the lifestyle. Shades of "Teen Mom."

That being said, I also thought the filmmakers did some good work critiquing them. In particular, the scene where Kirk is bragging about stabbing her ex (Dennis?) and the violence she would inflict on him when she saw him again. They juxtapose her saying that with her son body slamming his Elmo doll on the bed. Then of course little Tyler starts saying how he wants to slit Dennis' throat. Just showing the cycle of violence.

reply

Generational curses haunt this family.

reply