The Ward and Gothika (2003) - same score!
Gothika with an all star cast and great cinematography gets around the same score on imdb as The Ward, a much weaker movie. If you ever needed proof that genre movies, espcially horror flicks, gets a bad rap, this is it.
Seriously, it annoys me, because I love horror flicks, and apparently, I can't rely on IMDB at all.
Look at The Pact (2011, I think) - same score, 5.something. Ridiculous - it's a much better movie than The Ward.
So please, if you know any hidden gems with a 5.x score, please let me know!