Soo..Alaska won both all star seasons?

What are you talking about? They did not have all the same girls in both seasons of All-Stars and they did not have the same winner at all.

All-Stars season 1:

Chad Michaels (season 4 - 1st runner-up) (Winner of All-Stars season 1)
Raven (season 2 - 1st runner-up)
Jujubee (season 2 - 2nd runner-up)
Shannel (season 1)
Alexis Mateo (season 3 - 2nd runner-up)
Yara Sofia (season 3 - )
Manila Luzon (season 3 - 1st runner-up)
Latrice Royale (season 4)
Nina Flowers (season 1 - 1st runner-up)
Tammie Brown (season 1)
Mimi Imfurst (season 3)
Pandora Box (season 2)

All-Stars season 2:

Alaska Thunderfvck (season 5 - 1st runner-up) (Winner of All-Stars season 2)
Yekaterina Petrovna Zamolodchikova aka Katya (season 7)
Detox Icnnt (season 5)
Roxxxy Andrews (season 5 - 2nd runner-up)
Alyssa Edwards (season 5)
Tatianna (season 2)
Phi Phi O'Hara (season 4 - 2nd runner-up)
Ginger Minj (season 7)
Adore Delano (season 6 - 1st runner-up)
Coco Montrese (season 5)