I don't think she's any less credible than Knightley or Bloom on that score. I think there is some sort of bias against her because she's not playing a sympathetic, heroine. She's playing an ex who has every right to be ticked off. She's obviously seeking the love she hasn't been able to find (Jack ditched her) and she now wants the love of her father, no matter who he is. Jack revealing that her own father doesn't care if she dies, doesn't make her any happier with herself as well as Jack. If not for him, she could still be living the lie or dying by it. For her, being betrayed by Jack twice is just too much.
reply
share