What kind of idiot...


would believe a diagnosis of 90 minutes left in your life? How? How could one know that? Is Robin Williams supposed to be some sort of retard?

reply

Seriously. It's really a weak, pathetic premise to base an entire film on. This film is going to sink as soon as it hits the theaters.



reply

[deleted]

The doctor's word is the most trusted and relied upon ever, since doctors deal in matters of health and thus of life and death. But doctors are people too, who abuse this right of theirs once in a while, as seen.

But it seems the story doesn't end there, as he finds out she was lying to him near the end of the film, and then things should get interesting.





07/08/06... 786... the sentinel of Allah has arrived.

reply

Really? If a doctor tells you have 90 minutes to live you don't start asking:

How do you know that?

No seriously how do you know that? Is there some sort of chart that scales how much death I have in me?

Did this result come from a machine or is this your exact professional opinion?

What is the machine called that estimates how long I have to live? Obviously a Death Clock but I'm not sure thats the best choice from a medical marketing standpoint.

Am I going to get weak during the next 90 minutes, or am I all of the sudden going to die like someone just performed the Five Point Palm Exploding Heart Technique on me?

But really I need to know, how do you know that?

reply

Really? If a doctor tells you have 90 minutes to live you don't start asking: How do you know that?

Wouldn't you trust a doctor enough to trust what they say?

Have you never seen a doctor and received a diagnosis?



07/08/06... 786... the sentinel of Allah has arrived.

reply

You know what I've never had a doctor tell me?

"Your flu should go away in 3980 minutes"

reply

Lol, I don't agree with your overall conclusion but this is the best response I've read on IMDB!

reply

BUT, you have been told to take the meds and it will take 7 days to get over it!...

reply

Wouldn't you trust a doctor enough to trust what they say?


please tell me you're kidding. you'd seriously believe your doctor if s/he told you you had 90 minutes to live? LMAO.

reply

Wouldn't you trust a doctor enough to trust what they say?


No, i wouldn't, simply becouse it's common *beep* sense that there's no such diagnosis as "you're gonna die in 90 minutes". If they know you're going to die in 90 minutes (which again is impossible, unless you're standing there with a fatal injury), they're already fighting for you life, and not talking to you like friends while sitting in a chair.

reply

You have to be stupid as *beep* to believe something like "you have 90 minutes of life". So I guess Robin's character was downright, rock-hard stupid.

reply

It's not like she said he has 90 minutes to live without any context. He has a brain aneurysm, so yes, being told he has 90 minutes to live isn't outrageous. You can tell how long someone would live based on the rate of bleeding and 90 minutes could be a realistic time frame.

reply

NO, if a doctor told me I had 90 minutes to live I would, most definitely not waste time asking stupid questions!!



I'm sorry, I wasn't aware this is the Internet BOOK Database.

reply

He didn't believe her at first. His narration said that after a while it began to take on weight. Then the story wasn't so much about the ninety minutes as it was about what he should be doing with his life.

He was a rather volatile chap who spent a lot of time reacting, and not thinking things through (he used anger as an escape). He was also a serious pessimist so it wasn't such a stretch to think he could take her word for it. He might have even taken her word for it out of spite, just because deep down he knew she couldn't be that accurate.

He did have a condition that meant he could go at any time though. So yeah, with his temper, ninety minutes probably wasn't out of the question.

I choose to believe what I was programmed to believe

reply

bursting appendix.
But obviously you are not a trusting guy. by your avatar, i can see you are possibly the kind of guy who dates women that leave him unable to buy a pack of cigarettes without running into 10 guys she has had relations with....
Were you the more trusting sort, like the kind to remember to bring the rope, just in case there will be some charlie bronson stuff, you might believe a doctor, a trusted medical professional when they tell you 90 minutes till checkout.

Anyway, Catch you on the flip side.

reply

I'd have been humored if the movie was 90 minutes long. :)

reply

Exactly, OP. The "diagnosis" was gross medical malpractice of the most charming Hollywood sort. "Patch Adams" was merely tricking the angry man into carpe-ing the diem (that was a "Dead Poets Society" reference for those of you keeping score at home). Obvious cliched plot twist is obvious and cliche. Plus, "Simpsons" already did it.

"Ass to ass. Ha ha ha ha. ASS TO ASS!"; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oa5z77EI8y0

reply

Approximately 2 million Americans have silent unruptured aneurysms. Most of these people do not know they have an aneurysm and have no symptoms (estimates vary between 1.5-6% of the U.S. population). The overall annual rupture rate is approximately 12/100,000, which means that each year 240 of the 2 million with unruptured aneurysms will experience a rupture. However, the risk of rupture of a particular aneurysm can be much higher and varies from 1/1000 to over 100/1000 depending on the characteristics of the aneurysm. There are 30,000 new aneurysm ruptures or "SAH" cases reported in the US annually and about half of these will lead to death. Of those surviving, only one third will recover without disabilities

If the movie had been set in modern times than the patient might have google searched brain aneurysm on his smart phone as he stepped out of the office, or perhaps as the doctor gave him a minute to digest and then asked, am I experiencing a rupture, and If I am, why aren't I in emergency surgery. And if I am one of the 2 million Americans walking around with an unruptured aneurysm, is there anything I can do to lesson the risk of becoming one of those unlucky few... I do remember life before the internet, a diagnosis like this would lead to hours of searching library books and calling friends who had friends who had heard of someone who went through this. Thank goodness a three second search and five minutes now arms us with the beginnings of the information we need to question our primary health provider...

The information comes from here http://www.taafonline.org/ba_about.html If you happen to have a diagnosis, or are interested. I choose the first article to come up, just to see if the information was readily available, in case the original poster was wrong. There are many articles, and while these will never take the place of your doctors care, they can help you feel more comfortable while you discuss something I'm sure you'd find incredibly frightening.

reply

I could suspend my belief in the film D.O.A. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D.O.A._(1950_film) that some guy had to find the people who poisoned him with only an hour or two to do it. It's absurd, but given the time of the movie and the deus ex machine of "magic poison stuff" maybe that's possible. 90 minute brain aneurysm? Not so much. And worse, who drives in daily Grand Army Plaza? That, I can't believe.

reply

its a movie u idiot.. robin williams playing a part is not the same as him in real life.. wow.. so much retardness in the world

reply

Retardness? You mean retardation? Because "retardness" is not a word...

reply

I have not seen the film, just the trailer but it seems that she was pushed hard for a SPECIFIC number by Williams who assumedly needed such a number for some kind of hard mental framework.

So its not quite like he was in fear and she coldly said 90 mins....


That said, the film still looks like *beep* lol

reply

[deleted]

the movie clearly stated that he was already bleeding and could drop dead at any moment.
then if you factor in the fill in doc's stress level, it was easy to identify with the "comedy of errors" that followed. and this would probably be called a "dark comedy" ,
also it has a specific audience that it is targeting... just like transformers does. not many people would like both of these movies at level ten.
no insult intended , you are probably just the wrong demographic for this movie .
i personally loved it , but then i have never been the "norm".
NOW JUST START THE MOVIE

reply

qleo...thanks for the spoiler dickhead, oh *beep* it i cant be arsed to watch this film anyway

reply

simple minds like you are the reason i have lost faith in humanity.
your simple attack just makes me sad, because there are more just like you ... being bred by crappy parents,
I think deep inside , you know what kind of a piece of cheat you are, it makes you unhappy, so you project all that displaced self loathing onto anyone who ccomes into your pathetic little world.
the first thing that comes to mind ...after the disappointment of getting a response from a troll like you is a "your mamma" joke. something about my dkhd and what she asked for last night
but thats low , about your level and i dont want scratch marks on my bellybutton.
if such a short comment on my part creates some kind of spoiler for you....well thats sad on way too many levels
So take your shetty attitude, and just get the fek off my(or any) thread.

NOW JUST START THE MOVIE

reply

i love you

reply


no one loves me , you have found my weakness. in the face of those three words, i am reduced to nothingness. Those three words reduce me to tears.
(sheesh, no one loves me ...,what an idiot. who's he tryin to kid?)
NOW JUST START THE MOVIE

reply