MovieChat Forums > Don McKay (2009) Discussion > But why would he mail those letters to t...

But why would he mail those letters to the girl's house all those years?

posted 13 years ago by lukn4frnz
3 replies | jump to latest

Okay, he accidentally killed his girlfriend when they were young, along with a couple of his buddies. So he moves away from town, but year after year after year he sends heartfelt letters to her house? Wouldn't the dead girl's parents be getting those letters? Why wouldn't Don realize it'd be cruel to send letters to her house where her parents would be getting them?

And I will second what another said in these threads, I was disappointed with Elisabeth Shue. She's always been awesome in everything she's been in. This movie was mostly crap. Though I will say I didn't see the plot twist near the end.

[–] PutTheGlassesOn 13 years ago

I personally loved the whackiness of the movie, but I was wondering about him sending letters to Sunny's house, too. I know (SPOILERS) fake Sunny told him "her" parents died in the house from carbon monoxide poisoning, but my question is, where are the real parents of Sunny? Unless they did die as Joanne explained to Don and that was true, and she learned that when she bought the house. It's conceivable that Sunny's parents really died as stated and Joanne moved in not long after Don left. And she received the letters and the rest of the film played out like it did, but that still leaves the window of time when Sunny's parents were living there and receiving the letters. Unless they died before the first letter was sent and Joanne moved in and received them. But again, sending them to the house where you know the dead girl's parents live would have been weird and sorta cruel on Don's part.

And again still weird to keep sending them because he had to know either Sunny's parents would still be there receiving them or someone else would be. My thinking is that Don realized the latter and felt that as long as the person receiving them now wasn't replying back saying to stop, he would keep going. And when he got one from 'Sunny'/Joanne inviting him to come out, his interest was picqued because he knew the real Sunny was dead and wanted to see what was going on and who was pretending to be her.

If you believe in Jesus Christ and are 100% proud of it put this as your signature

[–] taxidriver8989 12 years ago

This is Man who has lived with the guilt for 25 years. That Guilt ate at his very soul. He basically an underachiever living his lonely days in mediocrity. He's a man who's very being and happiness died the very same night of the accident. He is basically shell of a man who peaked when he was a teenager.

TERRIERS/The Chicago Code R.I.P
BBC America Copper Sundays 10/9c

[–] rooprect 10 years ago

I think all of Don's actions are brilliantly explained in one powerful line he says at the end: "I'm not crazy. Just lonely."