MovieChat Forums > Death Note (2017) Discussion > Why is it so hard for Hollywood to cast ...

Why is it so hard for Hollywood to cast an Asian actor?


Nat Wolf really???????

The best things are last

reply

When I first read about this, I thought "what's the big deal?" Let them make a remake and cast whoever. That was when I thought they were just re-making the story. Now that I see they are using the actual characters, I am not on board.

Nat Wolff as Light Yagami?!?! I mean if it were Lance Yancey, maybe.

reply

If they wanted a white actor, then they should've at least got Ezra Miller.

The best things are last

reply

Ezra Miller for Light? What an awful choice I can see why people would throw his name around for L but really Light?

reply

It's probably going to be set in America though

reply

And in America the are many Asian Americans.

reply

A whopping 5.6% of the total population. That means the average person who lives in America has a 16 to 1 chance of the next person they meet being an Asian American. Or a probability of 0.056.

It's not really fair to imply racism or ignorance then, if an American suggests that Asians are not a standard American Demographic. This is a factual observation. Movie studios believe - people like people who look like them, and this concept is backed by various examples of scientific evidence:

https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/the-mysteries-love/201505/are-we-attracted-people-who-look-us

As a result, (and again, just based on math) most countries' movies reflect the higher percentages of their base population. The only reasonable distortion should arise when American studios specifically pander to foreign audiences, with disposable incomes, because they "feel like" American ticket sales can't carry a movie anymore. Like hiring Chinese actors, setting the film there, and selling their products. All to placate the notoriously strict Communist party of China.

http://time.com/2965333/how-transformers-4-became-the-number-one-film-in-chinese-history/

Traditionally this kind of cup rattling has been seen as a detriment to artistic integrity. Seems funny then, that once it can be used as a "tool for diversity" it's suddenly picked up by an element of the public, willing to scold corporations for not engaging in it, on the basis of its "practicality" as a revenue generator. Just what we need, people encouraging companies to embrace cynical cash grabs! Ironic then that this same type of mentality is what lead to the greenlighting of American Death Note in the first place, and most of the elements some fans find so objectionable.

Concerns about diversity in American movies might be slightly less about shafting, and racism and more about liberal idealogues losing sight of a few simple realities.. (Hey! I'm a liberal. Bernie Sanders for president!) I'm just saying, it's about numbers and a bottom line. If Asians are slightly underrepresented in Hollywood I personally would rather see them in more original material, rather than in all things spawned out of Asian culture. That seems kind of regressive. Especially since Asians aren't the only people in America who insist they are underrepresented, and other ethnic groups don't necessarily "have" whole countries with their own notable film industries, from which American movies with "ethnically equivalent" actors may spawn.

The really sad part is, despite the low Asian population, you have a nearly three times greater chance of meeting one, than any American Native... In America...

I guess I have to point out (because this in the internet) this isn't an argument "in favor" of "White Yagami" I'm fine if Light is Black, or Hispanic, or yes... Asian American. I just don't think people have properly put this into perspective before forming opinions. Based on that perspective, I'm not going assume racism if the movie turns out differently, and I think it's shortsighted if anyone does.

reply

All of your arguments have been thoroughly debunked in the past. You aren't bringing anything new to this.

A whopping 5.6% of the total population.


Yes, and that means they exist so there is no excuse to not hire them unlike a country like Japan which is literally 99% Japanese and has virtually no diversity unlike the United States which is a multi-ethnic nation but the mainstream media continues to ignore it.

Movie studios believe - people like people who look like them, and this concept is backed by various examples of scientific evidence:


That "scientific evidence" is completely irrelevant to this topic since it deals with sexual attraction and even that is bunk has it has been noticed that interracial relationships are on the rise: http://mic.com/articles/104558/interracial-dating-is-making-america-more-beautiful-here-s-how#.GYPdzB0Lz

Nonwhite Americans have no problem going to the movies and watching what are mostly white movies. In fact, Latino Americans, African Americans and Asain Americans go to the movies at a higher rate than whites: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/11/06/latinos-movies_n_4221232.html

Also, Hollywood movies are not limited to release in just the United States. Unlike any foreign film industry, Hollywood movies are released all over the world and these movies are very successful all over the world. Your Transformers 4 example is misleading because the only reason Chinese actors were hired in that movie was simply to help the film be released in China since the CCP has very strict rules about which non-Chinese movies are allowed to be distributed in China. You thinking it was because Chinese people won't see a movie unless it has Chinese people is flat out incorrect. Take for example the movie "Need for Speed". That movie made more money in China than any other country including the U.S. and that movie has no Chinese actors in it. It's the same scenario with the recent Point Break remake that also had no Chinese actors in it. Furthermore, in 2014 both Jurassic World and Furious 7 were box office monsters in China and neither movie had any Chinese actors in in them.

So if nonwhite people all around the world have no problem going to see movies with people that don't look like them, then it seems that it's actually some whites that are projecting their own racism onto everyone else when they use this unbelievable angle to defend whitewashing.

The rest of what you write is unconvincing. And again, it's nothing new. The idea that hiring nonwhites to play nonwhites being a "detriment to artistic integrity" is just a thinly veiled attempt to defend white supremacist practices that have continually hurt nonwhite talent for decades and decades by wasting their lives and skills in favor of whites just because they are white as well as hurting nonwhite audiences who don't get to see themselves in the same grand lights that white Americans do on a daily basis. It has been proven, that these white supremacist casting practices lowers the self esteem of nonwhite Americans: http://www.racebending.com/v4/blog/study-examines-television-diversity-self-esteem/

It's not that hard. It's called "equal opportunity". The character is nonwhite? Find a nonwhite talent. White supremacy however is in the way and that needs to be eliminated.

reply

All of your arguments have been thoroughly debunked in the past


Nope

reply

Haven't now either.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Oh please, good asian actors are way too rare. Besides, most anime just try to copy the west in appearance and style, it would be dull with asian actors.

reply

No there are tons of talented Asian actors actually








I'm gonna show you something beautiful everyone screaming for mercy

reply

Really? Can you point me one?

reply

IF we are taking about somebody who can play Light in this movie then I think Ross Butler(He is Korean) would be a good choice




I'm gonna show you something beautiful everyone screaming for mercy

reply

Name ten actors who aren't Jackie Chan.

reply

Ryan Potter
Ross Butler
Ian Anthony Dale
Jon Foo
Harry Shum Jr
Hiroyuki Sanada
Byung Hun Lee
Ken Watanabe
Rick Yune
Daniel Dae Kim
John Cho
Brian Tee
Rain
Daniel Henney
Godfrey Gao

I named 15

Class is Pain 101. Your instructor is Casey Jones

reply

Why would they cast a white actor in a movie that's going to be set in America? Its like asking a white character for Japanese live-action movies.

reply

You are very ignorant. America isn't only filled with white people. There are Asian Americans.

The best things are last

reply

Because this is a Hollywood adaptation to be set in the states. If you want an Asian adaptation (set in Japan btw), there is already one made.

reply

Your stupid comment has already been debunked before you even wrote it many times already in this thread and in this board.

reply

Not true. It's not "debunkable"

reply