MovieChat Forums > Jane Eyre (2011) Discussion > Seriously confused about his marriage pr...

Seriously confused about his marriage proposal!


Who was he planning on marrying?!? Who was he making preparations to marry (buying jewels, trip to Europe etc) Miss Ingram? And then during the "my spirit addresses your spirit" conversation with Jane, he changes his mind and proposes to her instead? Was he initially hoping she would stay and be his mistress? What the hell?! I would not accept that kind of proposal!

reply

He was never intending to marry Blanche Ingram, he only wanted Jane to believe that he was in order to draw her out and get her to admit (both to him and to herself) that she had feelings for him. It's pretty manipulative, but it did work.

reply

That is quite the gamble! Is that made more apparent from reading the book than the watching this movie? Interesting. Makes him rather unlikable...but yet you want them together ;)

reply

Do read the book, mydogvirgil! It's wonderful, and so much better than any adaptation.

This film is good, but two hours just isn't long enough to fit in events, let alone motivation. Try some of the TV mini-series. But, best of all, read the book. 




If there aren't any skeletons in a man's closet, there's probably a Bertha in his attic.

reply