MovieChat Forums > Madeo (2009) Discussion > So, who killed the girl? (spoilers)

So, who killed the girl? (spoilers)


I am confused. So the son really did kill her? Or the "boyfriend" I never really understood it. Unless we are supposed to just let it be, and take it as it is, like the Mother's point of view.

reply

The son really killed the girl, by accident. She threw a big rock at him and called him retarded, he became angry (as we saw in other instances), threw back the rock and it struck her down. All this was witnessed by the junkman much to the mother's shocked dismay. The boyfriend, JP, was telling the truth that the girl's blood on his shirt was from a nosebleed. We saw in an earlier scene at the photoshop that she was prone to nosebleeds. But the detectives are too lazy to investigate the truth and JP doesn't have a mother to prove his innocence.

reply

O ok. Yea I thought the same thing too but I wasn't sure. Now I understand why the mother broke down so much when she asked JP if he had a mother. I believed JP too cause I also remembered the nosebleeds. Thanks :)

reply