MovieChat Forums > Madeo (2009) Discussion > *SPOILER* PLOT DEVICE - JP convicted wit...

SPOILER PLOT DEVICE - JP convicted without proper evidence?

posted 12 years ago by jasmeets
6 replies | jump to latest

It's unclear.

1. The police does not know the motive.
2. He is not linked to the crime scene.
3. Zero witness, whatsoever.
4. His guilt can be easily proven false. Many people knew the girl bled from her nose, which substantiates his explanation for the ONLY evidence against him. He could also very easily prove he was going out with her, everyone seemed to know about that.

This looked like a convenient plot device to me. Otherwise a good movie. Dark though !

[–] jasmeets 12 years ago

No one ?

What you do in life, echoes in eternity !

[–] Flabrezu 12 years ago

Did you watch the movie? That's the whole point. The police are lazy and just want to wrap it up as quickly as possible. That's why Yoon Do-joon is arrested and determined to be guilty so quickly without any further investigation.

[–] jasmeets 12 years ago

And that explains why they would reopen a closed case just to settle it with sloppy police work. Genius !

What you do in life, echoes in eternity !

http://www.jasmeetsingh.net/

[–] Fake_Plastic_Love 12 years ago

Good thing this wasn't a cop film.

[–] KayDrama 10 years ago

It would do to keep in mind that this is not a film that takes place in the U.S. Who is to say, other than Korean viewers, if the legal standards the original poster lists are the same in South Korea. And even if they are,those standards are not necessarily adhered to in the U.S. either.

[–] 10 years ago

[deleted]

*SPOILER* PLOT DEVICE - JP convicted without proper evidence?

SPOILER PLOT DEVICE - JP convicted without proper evidence?