MovieChat Forums > Dune: Part One (2021) Discussion > Th Fremen should be Arabs!

Th Fremen should be Arabs!


I posted a thread on the 1984 version that the Fremen should not be played be pastey white guys. (Some disagreed)

A human tribe living on a desert planet for over 1000 years would have had a darker skin/complexion.

I figure that they will have the Fremen played by Arabs/blacks/Latinos in this one.

reply

Arakkis is a harsh planet, maybe only the strong survived.

reply

The book states that the Fremen were originally a religious group who came to the planet 1000's of years ago fleeing persecution.

So question I am asking is that after over 1000 years of life of the desert planet, would your skin color change?

The only analogy I can think of would be Australia, though they have only been through a few hundred years.

reply

1000's of years isn't that long. And the Fremen wear stillsuits all the time. Not much benefit in having a dark skin then.

reply

The most logical ethnic groups would be Arabs or, even better, Berbers. That fits the tone of the novel.

Latinos? Blacks? That doesn't make any sense unless you want to fit some politically correct quota, which seems to be the case, since they're using blacks.

reply

Herbert based the Fremen and their culture on various real-world groups but particularly, I believe, the Arabic Bedouin.

reply