Reviews


It seems that after a shaky start, in this case a barrage of negative reviews the show is finally getting some positive praise, which I feel it deserved from the start.

check out these other places of

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/arts/main.jhtml?xml=/arts/2008/11/14/nospli t/bvtv14last.xml


http://www.digitalspy.co.uk/forums/showthread.php?s=2aa662cab187d2b9e6 6b9af81eb7babe&t=932076



Bean Girl: Charlie Darling
...The needs of the many out weigh the needs of the few...

reply

[deleted]

Exactly.

I think the BBC needs to be a bit more adventurous in what it produces.
Okay there will always be a demand for Period dramas and reality drivel, the staples of television viewing but the fact that it is willing to show Torchwood, which can be very dodgy in terms of acting and plot and Top Gear, proves that at times it is wiling to take a risk.

What I hate is the knee jerk reaction of the PC brigade who would have us on a never ending nightmare of benign, safe dross, at anything which might possibly offend.



Bean Girl: Charlie Darling
...The needs of the many out weigh the needs of the few...

reply

[deleted]

"But I'd love to see heterophobic paranoid gay family members rejecting and shunning Christians, cos that's much more my reality"

Homosexual people are people and as a group no less capable of collective bigotry than anyone else.

Most potential family members in the gay death bed scenerio you describe would be atheists or agnostic (that's the current religious make up of most of this country at the moment) but the scenario of a gay family rejecting a Christian lover is an unlikely one simply because gay families are so rare.

You could have a storyline where a dying gay father's partner rubs up against his Christian son or daughter but such a case a health worker would take the father's view first as a patient and the child's request second (unless there is a civil partnership in there somewhere which are becoming more common place but still aren't the norm in the gay community).

It's a storyline that would take a lot of special circumstances to be plausible.

The gay lover turned away by the religious family (not just Christian) is a scenerio which still happens everyday in the real world without the need of a complicated and rare dynamic woven into the story (even if there are only so many ways that such a story can be told without beating the audience over the head with a generalisation).

reply

[deleted]

"Life is stranger than fiction."

Amen to that but are sure it's your religion your mother's 'hersband' objects to?

Besides officially, she doesn't have a say in the matter so it's really down to you and your mother (She could have married a man who didn't get on with you but a new husband couldn't officially keep the two of you apart either).

All the best from this corner of universe, I hope you manage to get back to talking and avoid mortal injuries.

It sounds like a complicated ta'do but usually complication is shorthand for a person/s acting like a spoilt child (something we can all be guilty of...not just the Romans).

Just keep trying, put yourself in their shoes so if they want to run away they have to do it in bare feet.

reply

[deleted]

Everyone will have a different view point or past experiences and I think it is refreshing to know that yours are not clichéd.

Bring it on.



Bean Girl: Charlie Darling
...The needs of the many out weigh the needs of the few...

reply

I'm really glad that the BBC have made something with such a radically different agenda and yet it's still finding an audience with atheists.
I'm an atheist and absolutely love the series, but I just see it as fantasy or horror because I obviously don't believe in the supernatural.

"The eyes are the nipples of the face"

reply