MovieChat Forums > Taking Woodstock (2009) Discussion > Vilma is always lonely . *Spoiler*

Vilma is always lonely . *Spoiler*


In the film we see Vilma is of most time a lonely figure. In the bar scene while people
are all having good time, Vilma sits alone at the bar waiting for Eliot to pour drink
for him. When Father, Mother and Eliot are dancing together in madness, Vilma is alone
standing aside and smiling.

The people Vilma accompanies with, Eliot's Father, Church sisters,are very unlikely going
to be his long time companions. Vilma carries an old time photo of he and his lover, but
the story of them is half imaginary. Vilma says his ex-boyfriend went to SF with Eliot's
friend Stephen as a couple, but this story is again in part unlikely considering the age
difference between Vilma and Stephen.

Vilma in the story of Taking Woodstock is a key contrast to the companionship and
sameness of the young people. This is very poignant since Vilma is the only person in
the story who states the value of his own unique being. And through Vilma we are able to
glimpse at Eliot's inner struggle. One of the instances that Taking Woodstock is not a
comedy but a complex mix of joy and sadness.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

Antonia_I

Thank you for the information, I find this very interesting. Schamus'
screenplay is written especially for Ang Lee, supposingly it aims at accommodating
Lee's unique style. In all Ang Lee's films, there exist characters of total
oppositions, and they are equally important in the story. It is through the
contradiction and correlation between these characters each of them reveals
his/her true inner self. Because of the very tight and dynamic network of
relationships, often it is hard to tell in an Ang Lee film who is main, who
is supporting.

If the source material doesn't provide enough characters to make up such
relationships, writers will create some for Lee. This is apparent in Brokeback
Mountain, in which those woman characters are mentioned merely once or twice
in the story but grow into full person in the movie. Also Ennis' daughter is
entirely a creation by the screenplay writers.

reply

[deleted]

You still don't watch anything you've worked on after it's been edited?


reply

The character of Vilma is the flanneur.

-- If Ewan McGregor were a lollipop I'd be a diabetic strumpet --

reply