I liked this movie


I don't understand the hate this movie gets I thought it was enjoyable.

reply

Why did you like it?

What is there to like???

reply

Agreed. This was a wonderful movie. Getting to see an unseen side of a story of people who believed in love and hope and peace. A mob who were polite and helpful and caring. I loved the scene at the end when most had left and a group remained to clean up the mess that had been made. Then there was the mud-surfing scene where we got to see a brotherhood between Elliott and Billy. The ongoing kindness of Tisha (Mamie Gumer). The strength and pride of Vilma (Liev Schreiber). The freedom and joy of Elliott's parents after the four brownies breakfast! :-D How Elliott stood up for what he thought was good for his town in spite of the horrific hatred and negatives of its townpeople.

This movie was a definite treasure I lucked into after browsing the DVD collection at the library. :-)

reply

Why do you ask these questions? What is there not to like?

I must say, I more than enjoyed this flick, it's wonderful and funny, it made me feel good and that's a powerful thing a movie can do (most movies cannot).

So I'd recommend this flick for everyone who's interested in Woodstock, in hippies, in love & peace, in a good and friendly movie.



"I don't discriminate between entertainment
and arthouse. A film is a goddam film."

reply

Agreed. Good movie. Not heavy, but a breezy, light, wonderful mood piece.


___
http://tinyurl.com/bpuzsxp

reply

I liked it quite a bit as well. The hatred of the film expressed on this board has been shown to be partially based on misinformation. People want more music? Do these people realize how expensive some of the music from Woodstock is? I imagine they paid a ton for the first few bars of the Grateful Dead's China Cat Sunflower.

The film shows a small portion of what Woodstack was. I found it to be entertaining and warm. Elliot's parents were a riot.

reply

I liked it quite a bit as well. The hatred of the film expressed on this board has been shown to be partially based on misinformation. People want more music? Do these people realize how expensive some of the music from Woodstock is? I imagine they paid a ton for the first few bars of the Grateful Dead's China Cat Sunflower.

The film shows a small portion of what Woodstack was. I found it to be entertaining and warm. Elliot's parents were a riot.


Unfortunately, plenty of people review historical films (i.e. movies based on actual historical events) on the basis of what they wanted or expected to see, rather than trying to understand what the filmmakers attempted to accomplish and judging how effectively they realized their vision. Instead, too many viewers egotistically judge such films by whether they satisfy whimsical, preconceived desires.

This critical fallacy probably exists with all movies, but it's especially acute with historical films. For whatever reason, Argo and Lincoln seem to constitute an exception this year, perhaps because neither movie adopts an ironic or "deconstructionist" stance.

reply

Good movie. Not heavy, but a breezy, light, wonderful mood piece.


... that description sounds about right. I haven't seen the film since it was playing in theaters in the fall of 2009, so I've forgotten most of my analysis (and I'd forgotten that Ang Lee directed the movie). But while it's not a masterpiece like Life of Pi, Taking Woodstock is humorous, ironic, and charming, while possessing a creative eye. Examining the business data, I can't believe that the film only grossed $7M-plus domestically. Taking Woodstock probably could have never become a hit, but it certainly deserved a much wider audience.

reply

It's a love letter, a fable, a fairy tale.

It is a wonderful way to spend two hours.

How wonderfully ironic that a movie about a time of free love would inspire so many haters.

Liked this a lot.

reply

[deleted]

I really enjoyed the film as well. I can see how going into it expecting a rock n' roll jamfest would disappointing, but as a film it's truly amazing.

reply

The movie started off with humor and then, for us, dragged a bit with scenes of acid tripping and romanticized drugged brownie escapades, receiving maybe a little too much attention. We were almost there. Not actually at Woodstock, but traveling in New York state in our old van, just back from a reconnaissance trip into Canada. We stopped at the highway intersection where we would have to turn to proceed toward the "famous festival of peace and love" that we heard about on the radio. We looked at each other and our sleeping five week old daughter, and said "probably not a good idea". After watching several Woodstock documentaries and this drama, we are sure we made the right decision to continue south toward home. This film wasn't so much about the music but the challenge of pulling the whole thing off. We rate it a 6/10.

reply

Just saw this last night. I turned it on because I thought it was a woodstock documentary I never saw, then quickly saw it was a movie, and when I saw Eugene Levy's name that added the humor. Long story short, I really enjoyed it.

However, the stage actors in the barn almost ended it for us early. But I kept it on.

reply

This movie is not a documentary about WOODSTOCK and even the characters are really not true to the actual people that were involved in the concert.
A viewer of this movie needs to keep this in mind, otherwise they will be disappointed.

But if a viewer just wants to watch an entertaining movie...just for that, then this is NOT a bad bad movie. I actually enjoyed it too.

reply