MovieChat Forums > Felon (2008) Discussion > Felon vs. Animal Factory? Let's discuss

Felon vs. Animal Factory? Let's discuss


Okay. I was more interested in Willem Dafoe's and Mickey Rourke's respective portrayals of cons that Stephen's and Val's. I actually cared more about Dafoe's, than Stephen's fate in prison.

reply

In my opinion, this is a knock-out on the first round.

"Felon", while clearly not a masterpiece, had much better production values, acting and direction. The prison and its residents were menacing. The only big mistake was the casting of the main villain (I forget his name), that looked more like Chris Rock than a real bad guy.

"Animal Factory", to me at least, seemed very tame. I expected more from Buscemi. Sometimes, that prison yard looked closer to a school yard. The inmates were pathetically inoffensive and the plot was non-existent.

reply

Animal factory i feel is clearly the better film, for one it's not restricted to only two places in "the shu" (they're sleeping area and the fighting room), the characters were overall brought out better without having to fall into stereotypes which i felt Felon had a lot of. The story was much stronger as well where as Felon felt very weak when it was outside of the prison and i just thought there were scenes which were obviously there for character development and nothing else.

reply

Animal Factory was the first film that came to mind after seeing Felon. I was equally impressed with Rourke and Kilmer's unconventional roles. When I was first watching Felon, I had no clue Kilmer was in it (I only knew about Dorff & that horrible actor from Oz). I did not even recognize him, but he seemed familiar, LOL. I check imdb while watching the film & I was suprised to see it was him. His character was intense (very Edmund Kemper like, but with a heart). I'm not a fan of Furlong, so his pressence did nothing for me. Dafoe was amazing. In comparrison, I like them both but I think Felon was a better film. It's more Gritty & profound. Love Dorff, too bad he's such an underated actor.

"It's pronounced,Bouquet!"

reply