MovieChat Forums > My Sister's Keeper (2009) Discussion > Kates sentence- and on another note

Kates sentence- and on another note

posted 12 years ago by brittany_smp
5 replies | jump to latest

theres is one line in this movie that has continuously bugged me and im really no sure why but could someone help me out? the secne where kate and taylor are in the hospital and hes taking care of her she says "im trying to spare you all the-" and then she pukes. i always wondered what the ending to that sentence would be. if anyone was to ever finsih it. what was she going to say before she puked? oh and on the other note. children should ALWAYS have a choice. especially when it comes to their body. if a father raping his daughter had medical benefits for a sibling would we allow this? of course not. anna's parents put her through a 7th circle of hell and i HATE needles. they scare the crap out of me and if my parents ever forced me to get a needle id probably hate them for the rest of my life. no no no no NO! on so many levels no. kate didnt even want to live after taylor passed. if she wants to die bad enough she'll find a way and atr least she is with the love of her life again. im suprised anna didnt need psychotherapy after her bitch mother put her through that 7th circle of hell. THE ONLY person who was using their brain and had some sense in this movie was the dad. everyone else was really selfish and the only ones who had the rightb to br selfish were anna and kate. the three of them shouldve made the decision and said screw you to everyone else imho.

[–] therosemcgowan 12 years ago

First of all calm down its only a movie. Second of all while I don't agree with sara particularly I understand why she felt the way she did when/if u have kids if u dont already u will understand why a mother would do anything to help her childand save her childs life.and anna liked helping her sister (did u miss the part where it was all kates idea?) Third of all kate wanted to let nature take its course because she was sick of the pain and the medicine and trips to the hosptial maybe taylor was part of it at first but clearly wasn't at the end. Clearly u need to read the book the movie was based on as well because in the book anna dies not kate. Kate ends up living a long life. Anna went through alot yes but she did it with love she wantwd to give kate her kidney but kate didn't want it. The end of the line that bugs u would have been (speaking as an aspiring actress myself) something like "to spare you all the vomit and gross side effects" I'm guessing your a tween or young teenager considering your needles comment and all I can say to that is wow how petty. I have been poked with needles since I was 8 (I'm 22 now) and all I can say is may you never have to go through that.

[–] brittany_smp 12 years ago

thank you for awnsering my question,and i am entitled to my opinion

[–] mmitsos-1 11 years ago

Anna dies in the book....not Kate???? I've never seen this movie, but am only just starting to see it now. Now that you REVEALED why Anna actually wants to medically emancipate herself from her parents, I do recall from the interviews in promoting the film years ago that it was actually Kate's decision to stop using her sister. But, you should have inserted "SPOILER" in your comment.

[–] emmeyc-1 10 years ago

WHAT!? Thanks a lot.

Detect my sarcasm. .

[–] therosemcgowan 12 years ago

One last thing NONE of them were being selfish they all had their reasons for why they did what they did. When you're on the other side of the hospital bed and near death then you can cast judgement upon the situation.