I liked Scott Adkins in this as well, but he just seemed too overly macho in the beginning, especially during the initial fight scene (honestly, who purposely sticks their sword into the ground to fight a sword-wielding enemy unarmed?) and the way he screams at Zeus in the sky after discovering the god having his way with his wife. He seemed to be having what TV Tropes call Testosterone Poisoning in those scenes. I don't fault Scott for this but I do fault the fight choreographer and Harlin for it.
I agree that he was over-the-top macho in the beginning but I actually thought that was a strength of his performance, not a weakness. This is a B movie so to say and Adkins was giving exactly what the part need - some bluster and machismo to make for a formidable enemy for Hercules. The scene where he choke slams the King Of Argos, beheads him and roars with fury was I thought incredibly badass but probably the best action scene of the film.
Adkins said in the beginning when he was playing the younger version of the character he was going for a very heroic version - he explicitly mentioned 300. I think it was definitely similar to Gerard Butler's famously over the top macho performance as King Leonidas in 300, the appearance too infact was similar - the short cropped hair, the big beard, the ultra defined abs and musculature, the booming voice, etc. etc.
I think sword and sandal films are the place to pull off such a performance if anywhere and I think Adkins pulled it off admirably. Infact I think he was so good that he absolutely over-shadowed Kellan Lutz in the lead role in every way.
reply
share